"I don't get it" V "I get it" : 5 Cigar Poll.

[El Presidente]

"I don't get it"   V  "I get it" :   5 Cigar Poll. 

 

Frame your answers on the following. Don't over complicate it in your own mind 

Do you "get the hype" 

Do you "get the enjoyment" 

......or is it just a bloody mystery if not a dissapointment to you

Let us know 

 

 

 

[Hammer Smokin']

get, don't, don't, don't, get. 

:) 

[LLC]

I get them all except the Mag 46 but that is likely because the two boxes I’ve had have not been great and plagued with construction issues. I like most other HU’s so I think I’d be on board for the 46 if I had better samples. 

[Wetduck79]

No experience yet but will be interested in the pole results.

[BigGuns]

Happy you did this, but having answered "I get it" on all of them makes me wonder if I truly get any of it!

[El Presidente]

5 minutes ago, BigGuns said:

Happy you did this, but having answered "I get it" on all of them makes me wonder if I truly get any of it!

Mike, you ain't got it to get it. 

[Bijan]

I said get it on all of them except the mag 46. Only Upmanns I really like are sir Winstons and Connie a. Everything else gets bitter, probably from me smoking too fast, but it's not like I can enjoy someone else smoking them for me 😂

[Corylax18]

I "dont get" the Coro and Mag 46. 

I've smoked plenty of both.

I think CORO is a ripoff, there are plenty of other cigars I would prefer 2 or 3 of for the same $$.

I've never had a Mag 46 that I enjoyed, even remotely. I love Mag 50's, I love Corona Majors, Love No 2s, I Love Noellas, I've got 10 boxes of PC's tucked away, but the 46 has never done it for me. I still have about 16-18 sitting in an SLB from 2015 or 16, but I haven't reached for it in 2+ years.

[bmac]

All are good except the Mag 46-snug draw on far too many examples.😎

[TheGipper]

I needed a third option for BBF:  "I used to get it (before 2007 or so) but I don't anymore."

[Hammer Smokin']

this place loves their BBF!

Not surprised with the monty 4 love. 

mag 46 has a smaller following...and that is being shown as well.

[westg]

Easiest poll ever,  I get them all 😎🌴

[Çnote]

Can we get a sampler? Haha

[Puros Y Vino]

Minus the M2 those are all in my humidor. But I don't get the CoRo and M2, the rest I do. My CoRo's are from 2009 and are good smokes buy I recall them being stellar around 2016/17.

[JZBdano]

Coro, I have to give them 5yrs, but I get it.

Monte 2, I get it when they're on, but they're wildly inconsistent within the same box and I don't get that.

BBF,  It's taken me 5yrs to smoke half a 2014 box, a handful have been shared and supposedly enjoyed by others.  I don't get it. 

Mag46, I like Upmann, the size is classic.  The older the better.  I get it. 

Monte 4, one of habanos best sellers but there are/were way better cigars out there.  HUPC, BPC and PLPC.  I don't get it.

[dominattorney]

I dont get coro. All the others I do. Too expensive for what you get IMHO. The rest of the robusto/Hermosa 4 all fill their niche. 

[BigGuns]

1 hour ago, El Presidente said:

Mike, you ain't got it to get it. 

But if I don’t have it, I’ve got to go get it. 🤯

[Rhinoww]

I think I just don’t get Monte much. It’s a rare time I have a 2 or a 4 and think “wow, what a great stick”

[Gamehawker]

I really miss the discontinued H. Upmann Super Coronas.
The Magnum 46’s pale in comparison. 

[riderpride]

Mag 46 and BBF are my only gets, though all of the CoRos I've had have been less than 6 months. The Mag 46 id easily my favorite regular production cigar, but rewards your patience if you can wait 5+ years. At that point it's all leather, tea, and salted peanuts. 

 

I'm drooling right now 🤤

[BrightonCorgi]

2 hours ago, LLC said:

I get them all except the Mag 46 but that is likely because the two boxes I’ve had have not been great and plagued with construction issues. I like most other HU’s so I think I’d be on board for the 46 if I had better samples. 

Bingo!  My exact thoughts.  Never been a big fan of the Mag series cigars.  At best good.

[Ginseng]

Yes to all, although my CoRo experience is several years stale and Monte 4 experience is thinner than the rest. But as for the Mag 46...see my sig. BBF, still good though not the glory days I reminisce about.

[karp]

I get the Monte 2 nut not the 4... strange... maybe one day. The Coro is a good cigar but I don’t get the price! Probably just a case of unmet expectations.

[Cazador]

I get all of them except CoRos. I don’t get Cohibas at all, and not just because of their price.

[Fuzz]

The BBF is the only one that I don't get. Never had a Bolivar that I truly enjoyed and wanted more.