Starting from scratch - 10 unique boxes

[JamesKPolkEsq]

Hypothetical: Knowing what you know right now, if you were to start your collection from scratch today, what 10 boxes (regular production, no multiples) would you buy? 

No reasoning needed, just curious what members have to say... 

[Derboesekoenig]

I'll go for 10, 50 cabs, because I can't have 100 ct cajons. 2 of each: Lusis, RASS, PLPC, Part. Shorts, Punch DC

[HarveyBoulevard]

No multiples...I WILL HAVE TWO OF EACH...

Me, lets see:

1. Punch Punch
2. SCDLH La Fuerza
3. Trinidad Vigia
4. Partagas D4
5. Partagas E2
6. CoLa
7. Monte Especial
8. Trinidad Fundadores
9. HDM Epicure Especial
10. Upmann Mag 50

 

[planetary]

As of Fall, 2018.  This is assuming some kind of "very good boxes of the last several years" quality level, rather than recent production.

1. Connie A
2. Siglo III
3. Siglo IV
4. Siglo V
5. CoLa
6. Sir Winston
7. PLPC
8. PLMC
9. des Dieux
10. Piramides Extra

[jackupster]

1-PLPC

2-Dip 2

3-Lusitanias

4-Boli PC

5-Monte 2

6-Monte Petit Edmundo

7-R&J Churchill

8-Sir Winston

9-CoRo

10-JL2

[presa_dad]

1-PSD4

2-PSE2

3-Dip 2

4-Boli RC

5-JL2

6-HdM San Juan

7-Connie A

8-RASS

9-Siglo VI

10-RyJ Churchill

[Alexw33]

I’ve tried to get a good mix of my favourites with a range of different smoking times so I could fit something in no matter the occasion. There’s some amazing cigars missing but here’s my 10.

1. Connie A

2. Siglo III

3. Siglo V

4. Lusitania 

5. Trinidad Reyes

6. Fundadores 

7. HUSW

8. HUHC

9. Hoyo Des Dieux

10. LGC MdO4

[Duxnutz]

 

1. Cohiba Siglo VI 

2. Cohiba Robusto

3. RASS (50 cab)

4. Partagas PC of choice 

5. Monte 2

6. Hoyo DC 

7. JL2

8. SLR Serie A (assuming it’s still current)

9. Upmann Royal Robusto 

10. SP Non Plus or RG PC.

[Lotusguy]

I’d get some staples and different formats for variety in smoking time

-RASS 50 cab
-Cohiba Siglo III
-RyJ Petit Royales
-HDM DC 50 cab
-LGC MdO 4
-QdO Coronas
-Upmann Connie A
-HDM De San Juan
-SCDLH La Punta
-BCJ

[99call]

1. Quai D'orsay Coronas

2, LGC Med 2

3. Des Dieux

4. Fundi

5. Party 898

6. JL1

7. Rafael Gonzalez Petit Coronas

8. HU 46

8. Rass

9. PLMC

10. Monte Especial No 2

[Doctorossi]

H. Upmann Sir Winston

Juan Lopez #2

La Gloria Cubana Medaille d'Or #2 (it says regular production!)

Montecristo Especial

Partagas Lusitania

Por Larranaga Petit Corona

Punch Double Corona

Rafael Gonzalez Petit Corona

Ramon Allones Small Club Corona

Romeo y Julieta Churchill

[Jimmy_jack]

Connie A

Sir Winston

VR Famosos

Cohina Esplendidos 

Quai D’Orsay Coronas (Impiriales if available)

Partagas D4

Partagas E2

Partagas D5

RyJ Churchills

Trinidad Vigia

[TBird55]

Esplendidos, but put them away for at least 3 years,  5 years if you can.

RyJ churchill

Punch Punch 

JL 2

PLPC Cab

RASS Cab of 50

Montecristo #2

Connie 1

Lusitania Cab of 50

HdM Epi 2 Cab of 50

Wow there are so many great cigars that need to be on this list, maybe you should make it a list of at least 20....

[Diabolicalpherpher]

Sir Winston

CoLa

QdO Coronas

JL2

Montecristo #2

Bolivar RC

Party 898

Diplo #2

Siglo II

PLPC

 

 

[Lotusguy]

Where are you all getting your LGC MdO #2 and HDM DD from?

[Stump89]

Connie A

Monte especial 2

CCE

Mdo4

JL1

SLR A

Trini Reyes 

PLPC

RG Perlas

BRC

 

[Ritch]

10 x master cases should about do it....

[Puros Y Vino]

• HU Sir Winston
• Cohiba Esplendidos
• BHK 56
• Cohiba Lanceros
• HU Magnum 50
• Punch Punch
• Partagas 898
• Qdo Coronas
• RyJ Cazadores
• Montecristo A

[canadianbeaver]

Cohiba Siglo 2, 3, 6, Medio Siglo

Monte 1

Trinidad Colonial, Vigia

Hoyo Epi no 2

QDO 50/54

 

CB

[havanaclub]

CoRo
Esplendidos
HDM DC
Connie A
Rass
Monte PE
Punch punch
Siglo 3
BBF
Vigia


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[JohnS]

2 hours ago, planetary said:

As of Fall, 2018.  This is assuming some kind of "very good boxes of the last several years" quality level, rather than recent production.

1. Connie A
2. Siglo III
3. Siglo IV
4. Siglo V
5. CoLa
6. Sir Winston
7. PLPC
8. PLMC
9. des Dieux
10. Piramides Extra

Pretty much the same as what @planetary said! 

I might substitute the Siglo IV for Siglo VI and the Por Larranaga Montecarlos for San Cristobal de La Habana El Principes. Then again, I might not! How can one just limit this to ten? 

[...]

Sir Winstons

Mag50

HdM DC cab

PSP2

Monte 1

P898

Punch punch

Esplendidos

RASS cab

Fundies

[wineguy]

Hmm....

1.  Fundadores

2. Monte Especiales

3. RASS-50 Cab

4. HdM DC- 50 Cab

5. Partagas D4

6. Partagas P2

7. Connie A 

8. CoLa

9. CoRo

10. Punch Punch 50 Cab

 

Wait there are only 10 choices?

[Raskol]

1. Connie A

2. PSD4

3. Monte PE

4. Trinidad Vigia

5. RYJ Wide Churchill

6. HDM EE

7. PSE2

8. HDM Epi 2

9. Mag 54

10. JL2

 

[joshhooper7]

After the Montecristo, the rest are in no particular order.

 

1. Montecristo No. 2

2. Montecristo No. 4

3. Bolivar Petit Corona

4. Bolivar Belicoso Fino

5. Bolivar Royal Corona

6. Hoyo De Monterrey Epi 2 (Preferably 50 cab)

7. Cohiba Siglo IV

8. Por Larranaga Petit Corona

9. Fonseca No. 1

10. Partagas Serie D No. 4