Popular Post El Presidente Posted December 14, 2021 Popular Post Posted December 14, 2021 You can't stop him Lot of pressure on Number 5 Bijan.......and you can't change your mind Big thanks to Lisa for keeping it all together 7
Popular Post Bijan Posted December 14, 2021 Popular Post Posted December 14, 2021 @El Presidente had me convinced on zoom I was wrong 🤣 I guess he can keep a solid poker face when he wants to. 3 1 4
Chibearsv Posted December 14, 2021 Posted December 14, 2021 Nicely done @Bijan rooting for you to sweep the board! 2 1
Popular Post Bijan Posted December 14, 2021 Popular Post Posted December 14, 2021 I voted before the video review came out but the limited support I got for psd4 from the video was the following: 1 Rob seemed to object to Ken's citrus note. Which would have made me think Jl2, or CoRo. He also seemed to object to his honey but not as strongly. 2 he mentioned it was rich at the beginning and again something similar at the end and they both rated it 93-94. This matches the last video review of the psd4 the guys did from 6 months ago. 6
mbrody Posted December 14, 2021 Posted December 14, 2021 How did I miss that one? Lol. This was a great cigar…and psd4 has been my favorite current robusto. But, I had epi 2 guessed first, Coro second and psd4 third. Granted, I hope to blame my misreads on weeks of head colds (gotta blame it on something).
Zaxeiler Posted December 14, 2021 Posted December 14, 2021 3 minutes ago, Bijan said: This matches the last video review of the psd4 the guys did from 6 months ago. Sleuth!
Popular Post CptGoodTimes Posted December 14, 2021 Popular Post Posted December 14, 2021 My sincere condolences for you D4 mates. My aged CoRo was sublime. 😜🤪🤦♂️ 2 12
inter4alia Posted December 14, 2021 Posted December 14, 2021 I seem to be in good company with my incorrect guess.
Popular Post Fuzz Posted December 14, 2021 Popular Post Posted December 14, 2021 I went with Epi no.2 and my second guess, which I discounted in the end, was a D4. I ruled out a CoRo, as I wasn't getting any honey, hay or lemongrass. I didn't instantly hate it, so that also ruled out Bolivar! 😅 To me, I didn't get a strong sense of this cigar. It smoked really great, no harsh notes or bitterness, but nothing profoundly distinct. 6
Popular Post Meklown Posted December 14, 2021 Popular Post Posted December 14, 2021 always a D4 for me. tasted of cream and peppers 5
CptGoodTimes Posted December 14, 2021 Posted December 14, 2021 8 minutes ago, Fuzz said: I went with Epi no.2 and my second guess, which I discounted in the end, was a D4. I ruled out a CoRo, as I wasn't getting any honey, hay or lemongrass. I didn't instantly hate it, so that also ruled out Bolivar! 😅 To me, I didn't get a strong sense of this cigar. It smoked really great, no harsh notes or bitterness, but nothing profoundly distinct. I got all smooooth lemongrass & coffee notes. No sourdough or partagas bell pepper spice. My D4 was obviously in the middle of a 2014 CoRo orgy for all these years. 1 3
B44 Posted December 14, 2021 Posted December 14, 2021 Brother @Bijan you sir are a legend. Well done. 1 1
Fuzz Posted December 14, 2021 Posted December 14, 2021 29 minutes ago, Meklown said: always a D4 for me. tasted of cream and peppers That's what I was missing, the bell pepper or capsicum that I always get with Partagas. It was for that reason I finally said no to the D4. 1 2
LordAnubis Posted December 14, 2021 Posted December 14, 2021 Interesting, mine and Kens reviews were almost identical. i had no spice in mine whatsoever which wouldve alluded me to D4. THey jsut randomly put bands on the cigars people, theres no blends for cigars. Importantly the only thing that matters is i'm still ahead of @Fuzz so 😛 1 2
Ken Gargett Posted December 14, 2021 Posted December 14, 2021 2 minutes ago, LordAnubis said: Interesting, mine and Kens reviews were almost identical. i had no spice in mine whatsoever which wouldve alluded me to D4. THey jsut randomly put bands on the cigars people, theres no blends for cigars. interesting you say that, Mus. i was 100% convinced (still am - this is all a set-up) that mine was coro. i love D4 and have had a lot of them over the years. never ever occurred to me that it could be D4. set up, indeed! 2
nKostyan Posted December 14, 2021 Posted December 14, 2021 THey jsut randomly put bands on the cigars people, theres no blends for cigars. Tell that to Bijan 2
Popular Post El Presidente Posted December 14, 2021 Author Popular Post Posted December 14, 2021 I knew it was a D4 from the minute I picked it up 1 8
Fezztone Posted December 14, 2021 Posted December 14, 2021 @Bijan impressive! Master cigar “sommelier“ 1
ChanceSchmerr Posted December 14, 2021 Posted December 14, 2021 44 minutes ago, Ken Gargett said: interesting you say that, Mus. i was 100% convinced (still am - this is all a set-up) that mine was coro. i love D4 and have had a lot of them over the years. never ever occurred to me that it could be D4. set up, indeed! I'm solidly convinced mine was a Coro too, Ken. No PsD4 notes at all.
Ken Gargett Posted December 14, 2021 Posted December 14, 2021 4 minutes ago, ChanceSchmerr said: I'm solidly convinced mine was a Coro too, Ken. No PsD4 notes at all. were these originally sent out on April 1? 2
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now