If there was a Cigar genie

[El Presidente]

What would you want the genie to conjure up. One time offer, one wish. 100 cigars of the same type and no ...not a refilling box

For me it would be a close call between the Upmann Super Corona and the Partagas Corona. Very different cigars in their own way. There are much more sought after 'sexier' cigars but these two fit every aspect of what I love.

Upmann in a close call.

[Colt45]

What would you want the genie to conjure up.

Hmmm......

First that comes to mind is the Partagas de Partagas No.1 - always enjoyable.

[kiwifruit]

Cigar I've never had but believe would be great, ED 109.

For a cigar I've had, would agree with you on the Upmann SC.

[Rye]

If they all tasted like the first one I've ever smoked, VR/LGC Marshall Adriãtico. What a treat they are!

[polarbear]

Edmundo Danties 109

or

Ramon Allones 898

or

Cohiba Siglo 6 Gran Reserva

[CaptainQuintero]

My first ever box buy, 2000 ten count monte 3, they were pure milk choc and dried raisins.

Lfdc short robusto an even shout to be fair, so different but both my only ever cigars that consistently hit above 95/100

Honourable mentions to qdo corona and Quintero panetela. I could smoke from a stock of those four cigars perfectly happy for many many years and be very happy

[riazp]

Party SCD 1...although I have never tried it, I'd say Diplo 6 just because its a diplo in a lancero format.

[LeafLover]

RASS in corona vitola.

[sharks]

One I'm still chasing 03 Siglo VI. From all reports they are fantastic!

[David67]

Hoyo Double Coronas

or

Montecristo 520

[nikesupremedunk]

What's the most expensive cigar in the world? I'll take a 100 of those, sell half, and buy different boxes.

If I can't sell them, then I'd pick either CGR or 03 Sig VI - neither of which I've tried but also can't go wrong.

[Lant63]

Anything with a MAY 94 box date. Month I was born in and would love to get my hands on something like this for special events!

[Puros Y Vino]

Davidoff No 1. (Cuban of course)

Dunhill Cabinetta (never tried it, but so much has been written about it)

[coug28]

For those of you that have a "genie" at your disposal and are asking for sticks you've never smoked before b/c they're expensive and trendy...you should perhaps also be asking to love the cigar too. If you don't, what a waste of a perfectly good wish.

No wonder the ELs and REs keep going up in price. They MUST be amazing if they're over $50 a cigar!

I'll take a few more boxes of 2010 Sir Winston and a 2006 cab of RASS please.

[orangedog]

CGR blend in a churchill format with a dunhill stamp on the box (for the visual stimulation coup de grace)

[maverickdrinker]

1994

[mk05]

Sobresalientes that are not tight

[dvickery]

just smoked one tonight...for the life of me i cant figger out why they were cut...fu hsa for this one...

allones corona

derrek

[khamy]

I'd take the Genie out to a very long lunch and convince him to swap jobs.

[jrb5783]

1994

First botl I've seen here younger than myself

[westg]

I'd take the Genie out to a very long lunch and convince him to swap jobs.

Him or her.

[kiwifruit]

Change wish to a car instead of a cigar. Would you wish for a car you have driven or a Lamborghini because you've heard it drives well.

[investandprosper]

Change wish to a car instead of a cigar. Would you wish for a car you have driven or a Lamborghini because you've heard it drives well.

Lambo. Every time.

[khamy]

Him or her.

I'm willing to wear a skirt to get this job.

[polarbear]

Change wish to a car instead of a cigar. Would you wish for a car you have driven or a Lamborghini because you've heard it drives well.

Is there such a thing?