Your Best and Your Worst cigar of July 2014?

[elam370]

The best was a PL Montecarlo. The most underrated cigar IMHO. The worst I had was a Monte 2. I've had a few great ones but mostly I don't have luck with em.

Oh hell yes. The PL Montecarlo is bloody amazing.

[Optic101]

The best was the HU Sir Winston 2001. Absolut superb.

No bad ones.

[Smallclub]

The best was a PL Montecarlo. The most underrated cigar IMHO.

Underrated where and by who? This cigar is unanimously praised on cigar boards for years.

[Smallclub]

Best: 2007 Cohiba Siglo III (these were awful until recently)

Worst: a very bitter Epicure No. 2 (from a 2013 box that was good so far).

[Bulldog4]

best: Connie1/Ramon allones gigantes

worst: behike 54

[hulklogan]

Best: 2104 Mag 50

Worst: 2014 Mag 50

Same box; first one out was ridiculously good, plenty of honey and fruit, second was quite bitter, only smoked 1/2.

[in0gravity]

Best: Bolivar Distinguidos

Worst: plugged Juan Lopez Short Torpedo

regards

Lars

[CaptainQuintero]

Best - 1960 Romeo y Julieta Romeo, will post up a review later, exceptional piece of art.

Worst - UK RE LFDC Short Robusto, the last from my first box and was pretty bashed up but still, tasted very muted and dull, pitched into the sea at the half way point. Odd bad cigar from these so far, nearly every other has been a high 90s result.

[dicko]

Best - 2013 El Príncipe, new box I see why everyone raves

Runner up - coro 2014, coffee cream spice slightest bit minty

Worst- h upmann magnum 46 2011. This box has been good but this was just bitter and full bodied but with no flavour

[subport]

Best: 2104 Mag 50

Worst: 2014 Mag 50

Same box; first one out was ridiculously good, plenty of honey and fruit, second was quite bitter, only smoked 1/2.

I think I am interested in those 2104 magnum 50's. Would you pass me one?

:-P

[johndalton44]

Best: QdO Superiores--these are something special. From the first puff to the last you can taste the quality.

Runner up would be Cuaba Exclusivos from PEL ABR 02. Perfect construction, aged to perfection.

Worst: RASS from MUR ABR 13. Fine construction but harshness for days.

[johndalton44]

Best: QdO Superiores--these are something special. From the first puff to the last you can taste the quality.

Runner up would be Cuaba Exclusivos from PEL ABR 02. Perfect construction, aged to perfection.

Worst: RASS from MUR ABR 13. Fine construction but harshness for days.

[joeypots]

Best: '01 Cohiba Lancero

Worst: '06 BCG. This one was plugged from an otherwise stellar cab.

[Pedro2486]

Best was definitely Punch Punch BAM OCT 13. The absolute flavour of these cigars is amazing, just punching through any other lingering flavours from drink, food and other cigars.

Worst was a My Uzi Weighs A Ton - bait fish. It's namesake would've been more pleasant in my mouth

[godpheonix]

worst was a partagas series D LE 2010. it just had tobacco taste with a bit of bitterness to it. very disapointing.

best was a Coronado by la Flor Double Corona. man was that ever rich, with notes of dark chocolate, coffee and orange peel sweetness which turned to dark caramel notes from time to time. mind you its got 5 or 6 years of age on them. but WOW!!!

[ShortFatHokie]

Best: Cohiba Siglo IV...everything you want in a Cohiba Siglo

Worst: Bolivar PC...still VERY young with overbearing amount of floralness

[Armaniac]

Best was a 2005 RyJ Churchill. Worst was a Partagas Serie D especial 2010 followed very closely by a RA Beritus Exclusivo Libano.

[Perla]

Best - Partagas Ser. Con. 3

Worst - Cohiba Siglo III absolutely boring

[mikek]

The best A Monte#4 90,Hoyo Epic #2 90 this box was totaly on!

The worst Bolivar Royal Carona,it just was'nt rolled right,the rest were very good 90 in fact,not bad for both young cigars!

[Bostin]

The best A Monte no.2 fresh from our host (glad I bought two boxes)

The worst A Royal Danish called the fat Dane and i left i like this

[madmarvcr]

Best of July 2014: RA Gorditos RE canada 2010

Worst of July 2014: Punch Punch from 2013

[OkieJoe]

Best: Monte2 (ABR 13)

Worst: BBF (FEB13?. (disclaimer, I was on the beach so It may wave got a little too wet)

[ShortFatHokie]

Best: Monte2 (ABR 13)

Worst: BBF (FEB13?. (disclaimer, I was on the beach so It may wave got a little too wet)

That's why I hate trying to smoke something good at the beach.

[earthson]

Best: OR RA Superiores

Worst: 2012 PLPC - still too harsh

[BonVivant]

best: MKO NOV 03 Trinidad Robusto Extra

worst: ULA FEB 14 La Gloria Cubana Medaille d'Or no.2