Rank your Petit Corona in terms of enjoyment

[El Presidente]

There use to be many more 

From what is available in 2016/17.....give us your top three. 

You start to see that with the removal of the Upmann PC (deleted), the lineup is getting mighty thin in premium PC. 

Bolivar Petit Corona 

Cohiba siglo II

H. Upmann Petit Corona 

Por larranaga petit corona 

Montecristo Number 4 

Rafael Gonzalez petit corona 

Romeo y Julieta Petit Corona 

[Philc2001]

My box of Montecristo #4 (MOB MAR 14), which you rated PSP/HQ mix has been absolutely outstanding! They're so good I actually braved the wind and rain from hurricane Irma to smoke a couple. But they are just disappearing too fast. If I could go back in time I'd load up the truck on these. This is by far the best current prodcution PC I've had all year.

Not a PC, but the RASCC (UTE FEB 16) minutos are smoking well, so they rank second. 

The only other PC I've had from your list is the BPC (ETP ENE 16) and they were too mild and tasteless, so I would rate them a distant 3rd.

Now if you include vintage PCs, then I've had a few Punch Petit Corona del Punch and Punch RS12 from 02 and 03 vintage this year, and they're delicious. So few left  

[Guest Nekhyludov]

1) ETP ENE 16 BPC

2) MEG JUN 16 HUPC

3) RGPC (single)

With another 6 - 12 months, I expect the HUPC be the best of the bunch. 

[JohnS]

If fresh, in order...

1) Montecristo No.4

2) Rafael Gonzalez Petit Corona 

3) Cohiba Siglo II 

If aged, in order...

1) Cohiba Siglo II 

2) Por Larranaga Petit Corona

3) H.Upmann Petit Corona 

Ironically, I was marvelling at how many Petit Coronas have been deleted in the Punch marca alone in the last ten years, just this morning.

[SCgarman]

1. Upmann PC  Hands down my fave.

2. Monte #4

3. Rafael Gonzalez PC

4. Bolivar PC

[Optic101]

In that order (very close together)

Cohiba siglo II

Montecristo Number 4 

Por larranaga petit corona 

 

[Lant63]

Bolivar
Plpc
Upmann
Punch coronations
Cohiba


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Lant63]

If fresh, in order...
1) Montecristo No.4
2) Rafael Gonzalez Petit Corona 
3) Cohiba Siglo II 
If aged, in order...
1) Cohiba Siglo II 
2) Por Larranaga Petit Corona
3) H.Upmann Petit Corona 
Ironically, I was marvelling at how many Petit Coronas have been deleted in the Punch marca alone in the last ten years, just this morning.

The coronations is still left. I wish there were more. The petit coronations is better recently if you are interested.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Lotusguy]

1) BPC
2) Siglo II
3) Monte 4

[WoadyCypress]

1. HDM Du Prince
2. H Upmann Petit Corona
3. Bolivar Petit Corona

Really want to try the Monte 4s just haven't had a chance.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G930A using Tapatalk

[garbandz]

" The petit coronations (Punch)  is better recently if you are interested. "

 

                     +1   

[topdiesel]

1. Bolivar Tubos 2

2. Bolivar PC

3. Cohiba Siglo II

[zeedubbya]

1.) Siglo 2
2.) BPC
3.) RGPC
3b.) SP Non Plus from 2013--really an excellent cigar. Has to be hanging on by a thread over the HSA discontinuation pit.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[ErikB]

Rafael Gonzalez Petit Corona (can be stellar)

Juan Lopez Petit Corona (always been great to me)

Partagas Petit Coronas Especiales (although it's an eminentes)

Bolivar Petit Corona

Por Larranaga Petit Coronas 

Sancho Panza Non Plus

 

[sasserjp]

PLPC, if aged. 

HUPC.

BPC.

RGPC.

 

[garbandz]

Monte 4 PSP..........best ever,'14

PLPC   clearance  ......best ever,'14

Upmann pc  hq..............best ever  '14

 

seeing a trend here................

[Schwartz22]

Monte #4

Bolivar

PLPC

 

The reason I chose Monte over Bolivar for #1, is that the Monte has been more consistent for me as far as

construction.  I have had a higher percentage of Bolivars that were fairly tight and had burn issues.

[dvickery]

My size of smoke ... I like them all equally ... can't honestly rank any pc's above any other pc's ... with one exception .

my desert island smoke would be bolivar petit coronas .

derrek

[Mattygukas]

BPC
PLPC (maybe 1 over 4 years old...)
MONTE 4
SIG2


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Toast & Taste]

R&J

Bolivar

Siglo II

Big Al

[tsolomon]

BPC

PLPC

Sig 2

Monte 4

[FatPete]

I enjoy the following petit coronas:

1) Monte No 4

2) Punch Coronation 

3) PLPC

[Akela3rd]

Rafael Gonzales PC
H Upmann PC
PLPC
With ah honorable mention for the almost PC du Prince.
Note: I just don't get the Cohiba thang and thinking about it I don't think I've ever had a Monte 4. Ever.

Thunder & Lightening '75-'15

[cigaraholic]

What they used to be and wish they still were...

R&J

Monte

Bolivar

These days...

RG

Cohiba

Bolivar

[NSXCIGAR]

IMO, Boli Tubos No. 2 is the premier Marevas right now. 

Can't rank them, but other solid Marevas I've smoked this past year are Punch Coronations, RGPC, HUPC.