H.Upmann

[jaiden]

I’ve recently become really into H. Upmann. Taking overall flavor profile, price, and ease of purchase into account, how would you rank the following?

Connoisseur No.1 No.2  A  B

Magnum 46、50、54

 

[El Presidente]

Heart of hearts. 

Magnum 50 is the queen. 

Love the Connie 1 as a regular. The 2 is special. I rank the B above the A. 

Mag 46 like the Connie 1. A regular. 

Mag 54 is a gorgeous cigar. I put it alongside the B and 2. 

Availability, the Connie 1 and 46 for everyday/weekly enjoyment. 

When you see a 2 come up, jump on it. The B/54/A are semi regular appearances.

[jaiden]

3 hours ago, El Presidente said:

Heart of hearts. 

Magnum 50 is the queen. 

Love the Connie 1 as a regular. The 2 is special. I rank the B above the A. 

Mag 46 like the Connie 1. A regular. 

Mag 54 is a gorgeous cigar. I put it alongside the B and 2. 

Availability, the Connie 1 and 46 for everyday/weekly enjoyment. 

When you see a 2 come up, jump on it. The B/54/A are semi regular appearances.

So 50>2>B>A=54>1=46 right?

[chasy]

I have never had a 50 or the No. 2. But No. 2 seems to be the pinnacle (outside Sir Winston). I feel like Mag 50 has been more available than No. 2 as well. Mag 54 is very high on my list. I love 'em.

[Lucas Buck]

Mag 46, Con 1 & No. 2 are the pinnacle. Don’t forget the Half Corona either. Affordable and delicious. 

[BrightonCorgi]

In this market, buy whatever you can if it looks decent.

[pohlmad]

54, No. 2, 50, B, A, 46. Can't go wrong but this is my rank based on your criteria. 

[Chibearsv]

I think Connie A and B and aged Mag 50 are top level

Mag 46, 54, and Connie 1 are next

Connie 2 takes up the rear

Please note: HU No. 2 is a different cigar that is also top tier. Sir Winston would be the pinnacle. 

[Ford2112]

Connoisseur No.1 No.2  A  B

Magnum 46、50、54

In order of my preference and experience as follows:

Mag 50 - refined goodness

Mag 46 - a bit more in your face

Connie 1 - good all 'rounder

Connie A - a bit more refined than the 1

No.2 - very enjoyable 

Mag 54 - decent smoke, but not my favorite

Connie B - I wouldn't know as these cost too much and I would rather chase other heavy hitters.

[PuffDaddie]

I love the Mag 54, my favorite puro.❤️

[Salomones]

I am sure the new Mag 48 will be the new favorite.

[LaoFan]

Of Reg Production I'd go:

#2 > Sir Winnie > Mag 50 > Connie B > Mag 46 > Mag 54

Everything else I can live without, although HUHC is great if youve only got 10-20 minutes for a quick smoke.

[joeypots]

It's a great marca, no doubt.

Ease of purchase? No comment.

Connie 1, great everyday cigar

Mag 46, A gem. Age suits them

Mag 50, Perfect size, milder than a lot of Upmann, complexity develops with time

Connie B, no fault found, ever, but cost prohibitive.

#2, My experience has been that the 2 is the punchiest of all the piramides but like the Mag 46 needs time.

[Mike Mecklenburg]

Agree with most everyone above and can easily be my no.1 marca from Cuba.

[Smatthews607]

Sitting here, enjoying a Mag 50 from 2019, and must say it is top notch. Not Sir Winnie top notch, but excellent. Love the 50 and 54. 46, not as much. Connie 1 and A are both great; have not had enough B or 2 to form an opinion yet. No. 2 is great, but different from everything else. Like the Royal Robusto, very good, but different. 

But truth be told, I would not turn any one of them down. Whole marca is my favorite. Was also my first CC, so might be a little biased. 

[jaiden]

On 5/21/2026 at 2:22 PM, Salomones said:

I am sure the new Mag 48 will be the new favorite.

EL 2009?

[GaryK 54]

On 5/21/2026 at 12:19 AM, Lucas Buck said:

Mag 46, Con 1 & No. 2 are the pinnacle. Don’t forget the Half Corona either. Affordable and delicious. 

I'm right there with you. The Mag 46 is one of my all-time favourites. The consistency of the blend and construction of the Mag 46 is outstanding. I can't recall ever having a dud. Love the Connie B and the HUHC is my alternative to a Reyes for Sunday morning coffee.