Your best cigar experience of September 2025?

[El Presidente]

Your Best Cigar Experience of September 2025? 

 

That cigar that just stood head and shoulders above the rest. That cigar that you can still taste when you close your eyes. Your best cigar of the last 30 days  

 

 

[MagicalBikeRide]

A 2018 Hoyo PR - it was amazing.

[Gemini_Man]

'15 Connie A. One of those where every puff held your attention.

 

[JDoughty]

BR 109 #1 by a very wide margin. Outstanding. Insanely complex and evolving. Utterly delicious with generous volumes of creamy, rich, almost juicy smoke. 

[Boss Hog]

Romeo y Julieta Cupido (BRM NOV23) smoked on September the 11th.

Price of admission may be a little steep but, what a wonderful cigar it is.

[unaslob]

This Diplomaticos Grandes Alemenia ESM DIC 23 answered the September call. I had a lot of great sticks in September. I didn’t expect this to be good as the last two were plugged. Prepared was I with perfect draw on hand but alas it was not required. A dark caramel slightly reddish oily veiny wrapper. A slightly fatter Lancero at a ring gauge of 40. A gauge that beckons me. Went with guillotine cut which seems to suit the gauge. Dry draw notes of cinnamon and hay. Lighting gave some peppery notes almost NW opus like that thankfully was gone in a few minutes. Replaced with toasted peanut. Draw was easy. Burn was even without need for touchup. The toasted peanut remained the theme with notes of citrus, coffee and cinnamon weaved throughout the stick. I enjoy the length of the Lancero as you can keep it in the mouth for almost first half of the stick. Allowing for smaller puffs and enjoy the cooler presentation of the smoke on the palate.

The Molson was certainly different choice. I am looking forward to the John Candy documentary and bought a case in anticipation of its debut. But will need to repurchase. 

[Lucas Buck]

‘16 Le Hoyo de San Juan - my first and it blew my mind with its ever evolving myriad luscious flavors. A new favorite and now I must source more with age somehow. 

[JohnS]

A Vegas Robaina Unicos, from the special release Sevilla Jar 2016, thanks to @loose_axle...

[Çnote]

Ridiculous 

[joeypots]

A tie between a Punch 8-9-8 Edición Regional Asia Pacifico and  HU Magnum 46, OER JUN 20.

4 Stars

[Hammer898]

This Romeo & Juliet Maravillas was the best. 

[Chibearsv]

2021 N1 Rosado was the most attention grabbing cigar of September. 

[Habanoschris]

Sweet cereal, molasses, chewy finish.

[Boxer31]

5 hours ago, Chibearsv said:

2021 N1 Rosado was the most attention grabbing cigar of September. 

These just keep getting better!! I went with a Maduro (50/50 pick) yesterday - great. I'm glad I got a few of these when they were available.

[Li Bai]

This 23 JL Seleccion Especial, but I expect these to get even better in a couple of years.

 

[gormag38]

TEB code BCE. Truly superb sticks. Although the POS 07s I've had are just slightly better if I'm being truthful. 

[Dlowil]

23 hours ago, Çnote said:

Ridiculous 

What is this incredible looking stick called?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[bmac]

10 hours ago, Dlowil said:

What is this incredible looking stick called?

Looks like a MJ23.

[rcarlson]

16 hours ago, Hammer898 said:

This Romeo & Juliet Maravillas was the best. 

Had one myself. Was Bad Assss!

[Bohemio]

Desnudo Ninfa, smoked both I received from a sampler, had to place an order for more, I can't wait to receive them. 

[Çnote]

10 hours ago, Dlowil said:

What is this incredible looking stick called?

 

10 hours ago, bmac said:

Looks like a MJ23.

Yep. I didn't expect to like it this much, but here we are.

[BG318]

It was a Cohiba Lancero. 

[abcd1234]

Hate to say it but it was amazing, at least it was "only" 55 Eur 😛 Cohiba Siglo III.

 

[El Niño]

10 hours ago, abcd1234 said:

Hate to say it but it was amazing, at least it was "only" 55 Eur 😛 siglo III

Man, I love the Siglo III so much. I wonder how much each puff costs me whenever I light one hahaha?

[sv_ontour]

Such a good mix of skinnies in this lot!

Upmann 56 for me. Not too sure if it came out of a jar but there was no LE label…