Which is the best of the Fatty Half Corona Format.

[Erm310mce]

I love all three of these cigars, so hard to answer. 

Right now I’m loving the R&J so I’ll go with it, but I could reach for any. 

 

[Pag]

Have boxes of all 3 and enjoy them all but the Petit Royale is a step above both.

Sent from my SM-N910P using Tapatalk

[Notsocleaver]

I'd rather have a Monte #5 than a media corona, so that's a pass. Every HUHC has left me frustrated it wasn't longer, so its kinda a love hate relationship. RyJ is a marca that I like, but only in small doses for some reason, so to me the royales is actually perfect.

[mt1]

Media Corona for sure because of the chocolatey goodness.  I have to say, I really dislike the HUHC, but I dislike H.Upmanns in general.

[Duxnutz]

On 1/22/2019 at 10:54 AM, Pag said:

Have boxes of all 3 and enjoy them all but the Petit Royale is a step above both.

Sent from my SM-N910P using Tapatalk
 

Did not even know this existed. I’ll have to try. 

[multi-useless]

The petit royales just didn't do much for me...  the rest of my box will rest for a while.

HUHC is good and I've had a few that were just "on", and those are hard to beat...  but overall I think I prefer the Monte 

[dcbuss]

On 1/19/2019 at 8:25 PM, Jimmy_jack said:

RyJ for the win. Also, they fit inside empty HUHC tins

Trying that out now...hmmmm.

[Pigpen]

Never had a RYJ Petit, but am a regular on HUHC. Not a fan of the Montes so it’s HUHC for me and a mental not to swoop on the RYJ when next on 24:24


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[La_Tigre]

Have all 3. HUHC has been hitting but those examples are aged tins from Havana. I need to grab some from 24:24 because we’ve only one left...?

R&J are a close second.

Monte not a fan at all. Prefer a Principe and far less disappointment.

[99call]

R&J Petit Royales kick ass.    I would say that the results of this vote will be skewed badly, as due the Royales not getting discounted by the majority of sellers. 

Basically the HUHC will win...............but the Royales is the real hero of the story. 

[RDB]

RyJ > HU >> MC

Both the first two can be really impressive in flavour.

[LLC]

A couple of years ago I would have said HUHC as they were awesome from the start. Lately I find them less consistent and prefer the Monty Media Corona.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Lomey]

RyJ for me, but I haven't had a RyJ yet that I didn't like. Great little cigar. I'm actually waiting on a box from our host and will follow with another box in the near future. I've had the Monte and it was ok. Never had HUHC, but might pick up a box since they get a lot of love on here.

Sent from my SM-N960U using Tapatalk

[Richard peters]

Have enjoyed all three cigars. HUHC are the only cigars in my collection I can’t seem to put any age on. For that reason The H. Upmann got my vote. 

[throberto]

I've got a box of HUHC and the Monte HC and prefer the HUHC.

Judging by the comments here I would definitely jump on a box of the RyJ if they come up on 24:24.

Sent from my GM1903 using Tapatalk

[rascalmonkey]

had a box of RyJ Royales that was one of the best boxes in the past 2-3 years-!