BolivarSmoker Posted October 15, 2009 Posted October 15, 2009 This is why I love this forum, because I have a chance to ask questions about cigars and can get straight answers from people who know and have first hand experience with them. I have tried a couple of Punch Punch and have had mixed results. I bought three from a LCDH (all from the same box). Two of them were tremendous. The other was sort of a letdown. I haven't had the Royal Selection No. 11 yet, so I was wondering, what is the difference and which do you prefer? Thinking about making another box purchase and Punch is on my radar. Suggestions between the two would be much appreciated!
mkz Posted October 15, 2009 Posted October 15, 2009 IMO go for the RS11. Just started on a 07 cab... Sweet tobacco a la Punch with a subtle medium body, quite complex, still with some youthful harsness in the last third. A truly great smoke with great potential, if you ask me.
mbrody Posted October 15, 2009 Posted October 15, 2009 I also say RS11, however, I can only base this on one box of PP vs one box of RS11 My PP's are "cardboard" and the RS11 is much more flavorfull. I hope I got just a bunch of PP Duds, as many have said they are great.
El Presidente Posted October 15, 2009 Posted October 15, 2009 personally I reach for RS 11. I find it more complex but whereas you can get very good fresh Punch Punch, the RS11 needs a nap for 3-5. Keep it in mind.
Kangaroo495 Posted October 15, 2009 Posted October 15, 2009 Having not smoked a PP for ages, my advice may be a little lop sided. But the RS11 I smoked recently, was simply one of the best smokes I've had this year. Medium body with cream, honey and (I thought) a grassiness about it. From memory, I gave it a 94. Enjoy!
tigger Posted October 15, 2009 Posted October 15, 2009 I prefer the RS 11, in large part because I find them more consistent than the PP. As with many cigars, age helps...
Justin01 Posted October 15, 2009 Posted October 15, 2009 I bought 2 singles from the same box or RS 11 assuming 08. The first I smoked was FANTASTIC, sweet tobacco, pepper, creamy. the second I had was one of the worst cigars of the year, basically a mouth full of dirt with overwhelming pepper in the first half then pepper faded and I was left with a mouthful of dirt.
thechenman Posted October 15, 2009 Posted October 15, 2009 I would opt for the RS11. In my limited experience the Punch Punch is good when on, but is sometimes way off...
Ken Gargett Posted October 15, 2009 Posted October 15, 2009 Neither! Look for some SS#2s! i would completely agree with this, however, one small problem. they were discontinued in 02, i believe. rob put me on to these on one of our early cuban trips and i reckon i have smoked way more than my fair share - mostly fabulous, can be a little hard and unforthcoming, but in general, wonderful. the best thing would be if habanos revived the line!
bassman Posted October 15, 2009 Posted October 15, 2009 i would completely agree with this, however, one small problem. they were discontinued in 02, i believe. rob put me on to these on one of our early cuban trips and i reckon i have smoked way more than my fair share - mostly fabulous, can be a little hard and unforthcoming, but in general, wonderful.the best thing would be if habanos revived the line! Nice candidate for a PCC Regional!
Ken Gargett Posted October 15, 2009 Posted October 15, 2009 Nice candidate for a PCC Regional! if only!! and in cabs of 50 please!
josie67 Posted October 16, 2009 Posted October 16, 2009 agreed...thank goodness I still have a cab of SS2 2/01
TrickNick Posted October 17, 2009 Posted October 17, 2009 I always go for the RS11. And they age so beautifully!
shrink Posted October 17, 2009 Posted October 17, 2009 i would completely agree with this, however, one small problem. they were discontinued in 02, i believe. rob put me on to these on one of our early cuban trips and i reckon i have smoked way more than my fair share - mostly fabulous, can be a little hard and unforthcoming, but in general, wonderful.the best thing would be if habanos revived the line! Maybe a Pacific Regional Edition in cabs of 50?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now