What should Ken and Smithy review?

[asmith]

While El Presidente is away, Ken told me we should do a proper review without the weakest link in the team, Rob.

So I will be sitting down with Ken to do a review what do you suggest we should raid from the Humidor to review?  Now it has to be something that is in production today not some vintage thing that was lost to the world 23 years ago.

[Jimmy_jack]

How about those Diplomatico number 2. Rob made a great case for getting them. I'd be interested to see how they smoke.

[skalls]

Monte 1 or el morro

[luv2fly]

Something old, expensive, rare or all three!

[JohnS]

Smithy, best of luck doing a petit corona! Ideally, I would love you both to do a current forum favourite such as the Hoyo de Monterrey Le Hoyo du Prince. Is there any chance you can both re-visit the Punch Punch again? You did a review a few years ago, I'd be interested to know if recent production is a lot better in quality.

[Jeremy Festa]

Upmann Connoissuer No. 1

Would be my suggestion

And therefore what you should review

 

 

[HarveyBoulevard]

Cohiba Espy should do the trick  

[...]

What about a RAG? Last time around, Ken was too under the weather to enjoy it so it's like it was never reviewed ?

[HarveyBoulevard]

Three Parti Shorts taped together end to end.  He Loves those.

 

[mnmlst]

I don't think you've ever reviewed any of the Cohiba Maduro vitolas. And since I've just picked some up, would love to hear your thoughts on any of them (especially the Magicos).

[Dimmers]

Something top shelf. Something from Robs personal stash :-)

[feral]

How about those Diplomatico number 2. Rob made a great case for getting them. I'd be interested to see how they smoke.

This

[Ken Gargett]

smithy, the deal was rob's best. current production normal stuff? not a chance. let me know the day you want to do it and let me know what smoke. otherwise, the door may remain locked. took me years to train ayala. i don't have that long with you.

ps - i'm sure we did the cohiba maduros when they first came out.

[topdiesel]

I would love to know how the current production Guantanamera Cristales taste.  Take one for the team type of review.

[Hurltim]

Hmmm....I'd go for a Diplo #2. I have tried two, (one aged about 2 yrs) and didn't really like them. Super spicy like an NC--even the aged one. Maybe they need a few years...IDK.

[Texwrangler]

I'd second...no wait...third, or is it fourth on the Diplo No 2's.    

[feral]

Just searched for a review of el presidente's current top four Juan Lopez #2. That's another interesting option

[Lant63]

Partagas salamones please


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Jimmy_jack]

1 hour ago, feral said:

Just searched for a review of el presidente's current top four Juan Lopez #2. That's another interesting option

I'd go for this but have boxes and know they are great.

[ComancheKeen]

Partagas Presidente, Dip 2, JL#2, PLMC, RyJ Wide Churchill.

I'll be pleased with whatever you guys go with as the video reviews are one of my favourite parts of this forum.

[Jimmy_jack]

I actually contributed! I suggested something that people support! I should smoke a cigar in celebration!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[archosaur]

Cuaba Diademas

[anjimj]

Partagas Salomones would be nice. We don't see much commentary on this Vitola. Preferably with a few years of age. 

[zeedubbya]

SLRDC.  It's been quite awhile I think and we know how much Ken loves them.  Have a couple tucked away and would like to know how it's going with them.  

[feral]

I actually contributed! I suggested something that people support! I should smoke a cigar in celebration!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Hahaha I did the same