What Cigar Doesn't Like You?

[str8dog]

Only had a few, but every Choix Supreme that I've had has asked me part way through, "Why didn't you pick something/anything else?"

... and BTW, I'll play the martyr and begrudgingly take all those nasty BBF's, Monte #2's and RASS off all your hands.

[Upmann2009]

RASS. Never get it right but keep trying

[cigcars]

ANY Long and Skinny!

[shrink]

Cuaba's suck. The only one I'm willing to smoke is the Piramide EL. But they don't taste like Cuaba.

I'm not a big fan of Trinidads either. Aged Fundadores are just O.K.

[hoyopr]

Cuaba's suck. The only one I'm willing to smoke is the Piramide EL. But they don't taste like Cuaba.

I'm not a big fan of Trinidads either. Aged Fundadores are just O.K.

Not a Reyes with coffee Shrink?

[amosnaim]

VR Famosos for me

[gersonmorelli]

BRC. The feeling is mutual they don't like me and I don't like 'em either.

[AussieCanuck]

Any Bolivar. I guess I'm just not man enough for them. They make me sick every time . Fair or unfair I don't even chance them anymore.

[LeafLover]

RA Extra

[coug28]

RA Extra

Funny watching these pop up on the secondary market all the time now and just sit there with minimal interest. Fan fare has certainly died down on them since the early ooohs and ahhhs of the dark wrappers & retro bands.

I'm with some others here...Bolivar and I were never intended to be friends.

[Rye]

Ohhh, Cohiba, why do you hate me? You act up when I try to share you with my friends by not putting out a damned thing and plugging right up. Whenever we meet, you proceed to kick the ever-lovin-snot out of my plastic the second I look away (I turn away during a transaction coz if I didn't see it, it didn't happen, right hun??)

You take FOREVER to warm up enough to enjoy your company, and you have more look-a-likes and imposters than Sadaam Hussain!

I try, oh I try, yet you keep pushing me away.

[LeafLover]

So far the RA Extra has been all hype for me. You know the kind of hype where you think, I'll just buy two boxes because I know it will be great from all the reviews. Was really excited. Smoked 4 in a six month period and have felt let down. Tasted like an NC with lovely cuban bands.

Have a box of RASS that I enjoy 10x more than the RAE I've tried. Letting them rest and hopefully they will live up to the hype.

[UpInSmoak]

ERDM Choix Supreme. I've only sampled a handful, and they all have done nothing for me.

[investandprosper]

PL Belicosos Extra. Trying to like it, but it's not giving much but straight tobacco.

[sharks]

Partagas 898 trying to love you aint feeling the love back though

[bacalao]

Another vote for Punch Punch

[cigcars]

So far the RA Extra has been all hype for me. You know the kind of hype where you think, I'll just buy two boxes because I know it will be great from all the reviews. Was really excited. Smoked 4 in a six month period and have felt let down. Tasted like an NC with lovely cuban bands.

Have a box of RASS that I enjoy 10x more than the RAE I've tried. Letting them rest and hopefully they will live up to the hype.

Got absolutely NO Habana enjoyment or satisfaction out of the RA Extra. Tried it twice just to be sure

[Jnaube]

Hoyo DC... Can't smoke them. I have a box from 08... Everytime I light one, I expect it to be ok... And then, it simply taste like crap.

[nikesupremedunk]

Behikes. They weren't necessarily "bad" smokes, but they certainly weren't "great" smokes as one should expect from a $40 cigar. They look and smell the best out of all my other stash, but didn't have much flavor. The rest will go to bed for a long time.

[Ssmith114]

So far the RA Extra has been all hype for me. You know the kind of hype where you think, I'll just buy two boxes because I know it will be great from all the reviews. Was really excited. Smoked 4 in a six month period and have felt let down. Tasted like an NC with lovely cuban bands.

Have a box of RASS that I enjoy 10x more than the RAE I've tried. Letting them rest and hopefully they will live up to the hype.

Same here I bought a box and have smoked 5-6 of them and everyone has been very disappointing.. Was really hoping they'd taste as good as they looked

[jazzbass]

Monte 4's... I don't know why but they sure seem to be sinus burners ... I've never enjoyed one... Love almost every other Monte.. Weird !

[Surucipe]

Partagas P2 and H. Upmann Mag 48 didn't return the love unfortunately.

Also really wanted to like the Cuaba Divinos as a short winter smoke but gave up after 1, we're just too different...

[Ophidion]

The Monte 2. Just can't seem to find one that does it for me.

Yup

[kevinfj]

RE's and EL's really suck.

Thank you

FJ

[Doug535i]

I'd have to say Partagas P2 doesn't like me the most, I've had a few of them from different years and none have been good to me. Partagas is one of my favorite Marca's and I want to like em , but just can't.