Best Corona Gorda

[El Capitan]

Help me pick a box for my Xmas present before I email Lisa. Already have a box of JL1's which have been supurb, and I'm looking to explore this vitola further.

Cheers

[cellinisart]

Siglo 4 are the best IMO of that list....if you dont want to spend that kind of money go for the mag 46 just be ready to rest the mag for a while.

[FireDigger]

Magnum 46... and get the cab if you can.

[Colt45]

Tough to pick just one. Love the Upmann and Bolivar, with the Hoyo coming in just behind.

You could always go for a sampler of a few of each

[ChanceSchmerr]

I voted SLR Serie A, but I would submit that the Punch Black Prince beats them all

[Onsto]

Voted Mag 46 but really like the Epi 1 and the BCE too. Its basically a good format...

[adic88]

When it doubt, trust Cohiba.

[LeafLover]

IMO the best one starts with a consonant letter.

Personally I would start off the first order with a Boli CE (like Bster), then a two box purchase of the SLR A and Mag 46 for the second order.

[yossie]

46 magnum for me but mines are too strong, perhaps because of youngness.

[winelover]

I went for the Siglo IV.

BTW - You've put SLR serie A on there twice.

[laficion]

Bolivar Corona Extra ........ ( even though it's a Franciscos and not a Corona Gorda)

HdM Epicure 1

SLR Series A

Plus all the others

[PADDYWHACK121272]

My head says Siglo iV my wallet says Mag 46

[hddeucebrad01]

Mag 46 and the older the better.

[bigfunkyg]

When on the Magnum 46's are great. My current stock came from 3 packs of tubos which have unfortunately been inconsistent. I really enjoy the flavour profile of the SLR A's but that might not be everyones cup of tea.

I'm a fan of Punch Punch but they dont seem to get a whole lot of love around here.

I don't have enough experience with the Siglo IV but it's on my list.

G

[tsolomon]

I would put the Mag 46 first and the Sig IV second. They are both good, but the Mag 46 is my go to cigar.

[bassman]

Even though it's not a corona gorda, the BCE is one of my favorite cigars & gets my vote. At one time I would have said SLR Serie A, but that flavor profile changed drastically starting 2006 & to my taste, not for me any longer. If you can find 02 Serie A, grab them!

[tigger]

Mag 46 is best overall, I think. They're quite consistent in my experience. They got my vote.

Siglo IV at their best are unparalleled. But they're not always at their best.

Love Bolivar CE's, but they aren't Corona Gordas.

[joeypots]

BCE the older the better. The loss of the 50 Cab presentation is a shame.

My Mag 46s from '05 are terrible and the old adage that age will not fix a bad cigar applies. These have never tasted good. Series A and Siglo IV are great, but I like the BCE more.

[mbrody]

Mag 46 08/09 are just too damn good and consistent. They get the vote simply because they have not let me down and I have the most experience with them.

Second place would easily be the 08 JL1. Similiar consistency and strong flavors (although different) as displayed by the Mag46. Sort of like the Mag46s stepbrother.

[thechenman]

I went with the Siglo IV, but close on the heels would be the Mag 4. It all comes down to your budget I gues..as you can't go wrong with either one.

[Habanos2000]

Mag 46. The 08's I have, have just blown my socks off in terms of flavor, depth, richness, viscosity. what else can you ask for?

[Dbone]

Our hosts stock of HQ and PSP Mag 46's are intoxicating in aroma, deep and rich in flavor, and excellent in construction. I can't believe how great they are currently.

I'm smoking out if an HQ box with the PSP for aging. I may need to get a third real soon.

[CigarZen]

This is just a great size, and all are great. What is odd id that historically Punch specialized in this size: Black Prince, Punch Punch, Royal Selection 11, and the Super Selection 2. SS2s rock.

[docbp87]

Looking at the list, I just realized that I have never smoked anything listed. I LOVE the CG size, but have never had a CC in the vitola, only NCs.

Have some Mag 46's on the way thanks to Raymond, to fix this.

[riderpride]

Mag 46; the Boli is a close second.