EAR: "Which one do I buy"

[El Presidente]

EAR = email assistance required. 

 

"so in short, I have the opportunity to buy a cab of Punch Super Robusto or a cab of Ramon Allones Estupendo but I only have the cash to buy one. The seller bought them from you in 2008 and is a stand up guy. Rob, which one has turned out to be the superior cigar 15+ years later?"

 

I have my opinion but I would love the input of those who have smoked both. 

 

Punch Super Robusto - Asia Pacifico

Ramón Allones Estupendos - Asia Pacifico

[HarveyBoulevard]

I was underwhelmed by the RA Estupendos...

[westg]

RA Estupendos . Never experienced caramel in a cigar like I have in  these . Amazing cigar and much prefer the size . I only have a few of the Punch left and never really found them to have to much complexity. Buy the RA !

[BrightonCorgi]

Both convincing cigars.  I would go with the one that is less money per gram.

[anacostiakat]

Love the Estupendos.  

[KCCubano]

Have not smoked either for several years but my box of Super Robusto never developed. When they came out all the talk was they have legs for 10+ years. Not mine. I would go Estupendos. 

[Hammer Smokin']

Estupendos. 

on of the finest regionals I've ever smoked. 

[Fuzz AI]

I was a estupido for not buying more Estupendos. Great cigar which has held up all these long years, whereas for me, the years haven't been as kind to the Super Robusto.