Recommended Posts

Posted

Best - GAT ABR 2013 Cazadores

Worst - ENE 2014 Lusi (in serious need of sleep)

  • Replies 58
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

Underrated where and by who? This cigar is unanimously praised on cigar boards for years.

Was gifted a Cohiba Esplindido from a mate that tasted like burnt hair, It lasted 30 min before I tossed it I really hope it was a fake one Best stick this year was prob a PL Montecarlo (an exceptio

Huh. So not just me on those Triunfos. I posted up a thread a while back on it Sent by the Enigma on BlackBerry.

Posted

Best: Bolivar Gold Medal 2008, PL Montecarlos. The Bolivar was still irritatingly harsh at the end, but the rest was heavenly.

Worst: PSD5, PSD4, this was during the days my palate was shot. Although it makes me realize the PSD5 really isn't that great of a deal.

The other worst has to be a young 2013 Boli PC. Too much floral and harshness.

Posted

best connie 1 USE OCT 11 .. sensational... i have 3 boxes of the PLM MAy 11 also..

Special mention > Partagas Lluisitania AUB NOV '12 and QDOCC '12

worst an ELDMCS TAL MAR 13 that thing was just tunneling and bitter .. worst burn ever.

made me scared to try the others... ill let them sit there for a while and revisit them over summer. when they have had 18 months

and a bitter plugged Principe AME SEP 13

Posted

This one is easy for me, I don't smoke a lot and I keep written notes of every cigar I some, so my worst was a JLP Cazadores , plugged as hell and my best a HdM Palmas extra Jun-12, smoked it till my fingers burnt.

Posted

Best - PL robustos de larranaga RE 2007. Absolutely wonderful caramel honey stick.

Worst - alec bradley prensado gran toro. Supposedly CA top cigars from 2012 I think. Tasted like wet newspapers to me.

Runner up - Hoyo Epi no 2,feb 14. A young box for sure, but the bitterness and harshness was too much to handle. The rest of the box is going for a looong sleep.

Posted

Best: PL encantos

Worst: Quintero Favouritos (have had some good ones from this box so think they are going through a sick period). One of the rare times I ended a smoke short of the nub.

Posted

Best: ERDM Infantes

Worst: plugged cohiba siglo 4

Posted

Best - Apr 2010 R&J Short Churchill

Worst (by far) - Nov 2013 Secretos Maduro - what a mission to get through one, then another -> back to hell you go!

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

Community Software by Invision Power Services, Inc.