Do you have an ageing regimen? Yes
In your experience, what are classic examples of cigars that require ageing and which ones don't? Most of my ageing experience is with NCs. A lot happens because I just haven’t gotten to them yet. But for intentional aging, some notes off the top of my head:
Anything with a Cameroon wrapper. Usually picks up/enhances a sweet, cinnamon note.
My favorite cigars are those that engage all zones of my palate. Tip of tongue, just behind that, the top of tongue, the sides, plus the retrohale. If that is present, then bonus points for balancing the flavor intensity of the zones. In my mind, ageing is letting the cigar evolve toward that balance. If each zone is a surround sound speaker, I want to hear every instrument of the orchestra at the appropriate volume.
Cigars with a creamy texture smoke versus an oily texture smoke. It’s been my experience that creamy smokes will become more balanced more quickly than oily ones. Many oily ones may change, but not toward balance Ones that do, it takes a lot longer than creamy ones.
In your experience, what are classic examples of cigars that you believe "peak" after a certain period of time? What is the time period roughly? The previously mentioned Camerron cinnamon thing is 4-8 years.
Have you ever been confronted with a cigar thay you have stored that has "expired"? What was it? Old Jamaican cigars. Pretty mild to start and after 15+ years, not much flavor left.
What is your temp and RH for storage? 65% rh, house temp 70f-ish
Do you vaccuum seal/shrink wrap your cigars? If you do, what has been your experience? Have you witnessed better results on some cigars/marques than others? How long have you been doing it for? Are you a convert? No, but I’m going to look into what Cory wrote.
Any advice to other members? While it may seem wasteful or weird, smoking 4 (or more?) cigars at once (various ages) and getting instant comparisons is worth the education.