"......never had a bad one"

[MeLlamoHabano]

I think its fair if I only count cigars that I’ve had double digits of, considering that criteria...

Siglo II

HUHC

[VasileDulap]

Trinidad Reyes

[gormag38]

5 hours ago, joeypots said:

Siglo III

This was my first thought too. I've had a number over a number of different boxes/years/codes. They're just great. E2s are another one I've thought of too. 

[dan05]

As I am learning the culinary side of cigars, I’d love to hear what @El Presidente and @Ken Gargett would choose as their 'never had a bad one cigar/cigars'.

It would be nice for me to have a little list of the ones that are great so I don’t spend any $ on duds in my learning phase. Just to build a good base of flavour profiled vs. brand. 

[Boss Hog]

💋 🫏 

[HDGSN]

Sir Winston

[Puros Y Vino]

PSD4. From 2004, 2008, 2009, 2010 boxes. Never a bad one or a even a disappointing one.

[REesq]

The two that come to my mind are BBFs (other than one box of aged 2001s that I bought and which clearly not been stored well) and Lusis. Probably Esplendidos as well. The 4 or 5 boxes I’ve had of those over the years were always great. I’ve had a number of bad ones, but they were always singles, almost always given to me and always of questionable providence.

[teamrandr]

Trinidad Reyes, but it has been years since I had one sadly.

[chasy]

If we do a Never Had a Good One, my vote is QdO 50.

[jfestrelabr]

RyJ Wide

Partagas SE2

[Ciscojohansson]

E2 for sure and never had a bad D6. 

19 hours ago, chasy said:

If we do a Never Had a Good One, my vote is QdO 50.

This is a great idea!

[MPS]

Monsdale 

[Perla]

PL Montecarlos

Trinidad Reyes

ERDM Demitasse 

Montecristo Esp. 2

Siglo 3, 5 & 6