Recommended Posts

Posted

Fair market value is whatever someone is willing to pay and as long as there are bored rich folks looking for a dopamine hit, this kinda thing will exist. 

  • Like 1
Posted

I can't blame them for making a product that people will buy. However, with their low-mid grade products (B.T. and Weller S.R.) being "allocated" in many places, the attention and fame has gone to their heads.

Meanwhile, W.T. Rare Breed which is sitting on supermarket shelves at $55 will likely blow the doors off this unattainable $7,500 bottle in a blind test. 

  • Like 3
Posted

my thoughts were the same as Chitmo. whatever people are willing to pay. it is why cigars have gone through the roof. and burgundy and a great many other things. probably not unattainable if you have the money and you know where to look. and i suspect that it would most likely blow the doors off fifty buck bottles, rather than the reverse, but we buy what we can. the buffalo trace distillery makes some sensational bourbon. there would be bourbons, i suspect, at a fraction of the price which make the price differential seem absurd. 

what i find a bit of a shame is all the money which goes into presentation. i know some love it and they keep having to top competitors but i'd rather better pricing and normal bottles. mind you, would still be a mile out of my range. 

  • Like 2
Posted
7 minutes ago, Ken Gargett said:

my thoughts were the same as Chitmo. whatever people are willing to pay. it is why cigars have gone through the roof. and burgundy and a great many other things. probably not unattainable if you have the money and you know where to look. and i suspect that it would most likely blow the doors off fifty buck bottles, rather than the reverse, but we buy what we can. the buffalo trace distillery makes some sensational bourbon. there would be bourbons, i suspect, at a fraction of the price which make the price differential seem absurd. 

what i find a bit of a shame is all the money which goes into presentation. i know some love it and they keep having to top competitors but i'd rather better pricing and normal bottles. mind you, would still be a mile out of my range. 

It’s all for the Instagram , ticker tocker crowd of projectionists. 

  • Like 1
Posted
7 hours ago, Ken Gargett said:

i suspect that it would most likely blow the doors off fifty buck bottles

The price of American whiskey is an incredibly poor predictor of quality over $40-$50 a bottle. Nothing like wine. American whiskeys are easily overaged, as I suspect this one is, though ultimately blending is the key. It’s why the best bourbon I’ve had in many years (Barrell Vantage) blows the doors of bottles many times it’s value, and is cask strength to boot. 

  • Like 3
Posted
6 hours ago, MrBirdman said:

The price of American whiskey is an incredibly poor predictor of quality over $40-$50 a bottle. Nothing like wine. American whiskeys are easily overaged, as I suspect this one is, though ultimately blending is the key. It’s why the best bourbon I’ve had in many years (Barrell Vantage) blows the doors of bottles many times it’s value, and is cask strength to boot. 

i suspect that is true for most spirits around the world, in varying degrees, but it would still be a pretty poor effort for a $7500 bottle to be knocked over easily by a fifty buck bottle. word would quickly get around and the rep of the distillery would crater. these guys do have an excellent reputation and have made many cracking bourbons. if this sort of thing appealed to me and i had the dosh, i'd reckon they have a reputation such that they are good enough not to be putting out duds at this level. 

  • Like 2
Posted
1 hour ago, Ken Gargett said:

it would still be a pretty poor effort for a $7500 bottle to be knocked over easily by a fifty buck bottle. word would quickly get around and the rep of the distillery would crater.

It’s Buffalo Trace. Their reputation ain’t going nowhere. Most American whiskey is made by a handful of distilleries - most of those brands you see are blends of whiskey distilled by others. And marketing!

I have no idea how this tastes, I’m sure it will be excellent. Just probably not any better than a good $100-150 bottle ($50 is too low these days.) Again, this isn’t wine. This is 98% marketing and packaging, hence the Habanos reference by Rob. 

  • Like 3

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

Community Software by Invision Power Services, Inc.