You have the keys: Nominate.....

[bobbutcher]

Ramon Allones 898s

[noreaster]

Dantes 109...

[Guest robustog]

dip #4

[Chaki]

Partagas Lonsdales

[BonVivant]

My favorite petit corona... H Upmann Club Epicur

Cohiba Siglo II with different bands and packaging from the same year you mean?

€100 on release cigars?

Bring it on!

[ChanceSchmerr]

You should hook a BOTL up! Go get him Chancer!

I'm still kind of in shock that someone actually has some!

[CanuckSARTech]

LGC #2

Not discontinued.

[CanuckSARTech]

I agree with many others - RA 898's (although I actually haven't had one recently, but I love the format and the RA blend, so it's a shoe-in), with Dip 4's as the runner up.

[BonVivant]

My favorite petit corona... H Upmann Club Epicur

Cohiba Siglo II is still available

[Wicky]

Coronas Extra Largas would be nice.

[AverageJoe83]

For me it would be H.Upmann Petit Upmann, good enough for Kennedy, good enough for me.

[LGC]

Cohiba Siglo II with different bands and packaging from the same year you mean?

€100 on release cigars?

Bring it on!

You're confusing these with the 2000 Festival Marevas. They're different cigars.

I disagree about the Festival Marevas being rebanded Siglo II's. I've never smoked a Siglo II that really impressed me. I trust you're basing your assumptions on having smoked a fair number of Festival Marevas... in order to make an accurate statement...

[AlohaStyle]

I couldn't just choose 1!?! In order... (thanks for pics Trevor, love your site!)

Dunhill Cabinetta

LFDC Short Churchill

LGC Glorias (6.4" x 46)

[AverageJoe83]

I trust you're basing your assumptions on having smoked a fair number of Festival Marevas... in order to make an accurate statement...

Doubtful... He seems to be haveing a go at you... but mine is the post that gets edited...LOL.

[in0gravity]

Dunhill Cabinetta for me

[AntiVirus]

LGC Medaille d'Or No.1

[mazolaman]

You should hook a BOTL up! Go get him Chancer!

Damn right, it is Christmas.

[hanhan]

Only one choice? Assuming that limited production cigars like the 1492 are left out.... Hmmmm... It would have to be either Dunhill or Punch but it would be hard chosing between Ninfas, SS 1,2, RS 11, or Monarcas. If forced to choose, would probably go with the Monarcas.

If dunhill, Don Candido Selección No.504.

[Styler]

It's a tough call between the RA 898 and the Partagas SdC #3

[Michel1968]

RyJ Bully

I would have chosen the Clemenceaus but I don't have the time for churchills!

Smoked a Clemenceaus few weeks ago... cigar of the year for me. Very tempting to choose this one. Still my key would fit the lock attached to LGC M'dOr #1.

[dB69]

Of those I have smoked it would be 10 cabinets of Partagas Lonsdales.

Of those I have never even seen my choice would be 10 boxes of La Escepcion Cazadores Miramar.

Original Bolivar Gold Medals wouldn't be a bad choice either..

[ned]

i would go with some of the original release behike

[anacostiakat]

Tough choice.

First thought is RA 898 as others have chosen.

There are just so many.

[Ryan]

All of the ones mentioned so far I'd agree with.

Add La Flor de Cano Diadema.

[mk05]

Couple great thoughts here. Clemenceau, DC 504, Punch Monarca...

Me, Santa Felipa Mundiales.