Top 5 Cigars in my Humidor

[Jaksen]

Let’s take a look at the absolute best my humidor has to offer in regular production cigars…

5. Partagas D #4

A lovely strong and spicy cigar. Perfect after a barbeque or with a bottle of Pinot Noir.

4. Trinidad Robusto Extra

In Denmark we are blessed with some of the most delightful licorice made by old traditional methods. The Trinidad Robusto Extra is a really close substitute with a lovely creamy aroma. Far superior to the Montecristo No. 2 which has a similar flavor profile.

3. Vegas Robaina Famosos

Imagine the best roasted cup of coffee you have ever had. This cigar is the essence of the imagination. Enjoy it with a shot of dupo espresso. Don Alejandro, what a legend, Rest In Peace!

2. Bolivar Royal Corona

This cigar can challenge any cigar out there on the sweet’n’sour flavor profile. Try it with a bottle of Muscato d’Asti.

1. Partagas P #2

A rich creamy smoke like no other. A symphony of nutty, coffee and oaky flavors. I allways pare it with a hot cup of Pukka “Three Berry” tea.

[cigarros]

Nice choice! Thx for sharing! So what is licorice name you're comparing with?

[bassman]

Funny how tastes differ. Not only are none favorites, but I don't even own any of the five.

My top 5 in my Humidor

97 Bolivar Corona Gigante cab. Rarely does such a large cigar have power AND complexity.

01 SLR DC- still waiting for a subsequent year to come even close

02 Partagas Lonsdale cab. Hard to find, but if one comes available I'll buy it. Currently have 3 cabs

02 Bolivar CE cabs. Pure power & earth.

06 MC#2 Overpowering chocolate flavor

[Colt45]

Tough for me to go with five, but as usual, my top two are the Upmann Sir Winston and Bolivar Corona Gigantes.

[CigarmanTim]

The top 5 in my humidor:

5. PLPC ....still needs another 2 years on this cab.

4. Monte #2 HQ '08

3. PSP2 HQ

2. BRC HQ my hq's are to die for. My PE are overly blended with ligero

1. Partagas Lusitania......... I have 1 (10) pf PE, HQ and PSP I smoke only the HQ and PE.....both are great and never ever let me down.

[agentdaffy007]

My top 5 is like this:

5) Partagas PSD#4

4) Cohiba Robusto

3) Trinidad Coloniales

2) Ramon Allones Specially Selected

1) Hoyo de Monterrey Petit Robusto

[LeafLover]

Top 5 (in no particular order):

JL No. 1

Partagas D4

ScdH El Prinicpe/Parti short (tie)

SLR A

H Upmann 46

[Habanos2000]

I only have 5 in my humidor that I've tried, with a 10 ct Party 898 HQ that's still resting plus a few odds and ends singles, but the rest looks like this:

Mag 46 (PSP) Disgustingly decadent!

Mag 50

Dip 4

Punch PC (PSP) Outstanding! I have 2 boxes because of a mix up, and boy am I glad that happened now!

BRC

[mm12]

My top 5:

5. 08 Bolivar Corona Gigante- chocolate, rootbeer, and earth

4. 07 Ramon Allones Estupendos- sour cream and rich cheese

3. 02 LGC Medaille d'or no. 1- absolutely dripping with honey

2. 08 Partagas Lusitania- strong, typical wood/earth/spice Partagas profile. Can't wait for these to get some years on them

1. 01 Ramon Allones 898- very full bodied, wood, cream, earth, christmas spice, longest finish I've ever seen in a cigar by far

Edit: 07 Punch Royal Selection 11 belongs on this list somewhere Maybe 3 or 4.

[ksblazer]

In no particular order:

2001 Punch Super Selection No.2

1998 Vegas Robaina Classicos

2003 H. Upmann Sir Winston

2002 La Gloria Cubana Medaille De Or No.1

2001 Partagas Lonsdales

[mbrody]

In no particular order:

Mag 50 Tubo, bought late 09

Mag 46 early 08

Juan Lopez #2 Late 07

Juan Lopez #1 08

Boli CJ 07

[Bartolomeo]

Top 5 that I am smoking currently, not Top 5 overall

JL #1 2001

Upmann #2 2008

ERDM Lunch Club ?

ERDM GC 2001

SLR Regios 2000

Bart

[dcse]

BBF

Bolivar Especiales no 2, German Regional Edition

Ramon Allones Phoenicio, Middle East Regional Edition

H. Upmann Dunhill Selection Suprema no 23

Bolivar Coronas Gigantes (1990)

[Ellery]

In no order:

Trini T

Boli PC

VR Famosos

Mag 46

SLR regios

[khomeinist]

98 Trinidad Fundadores

02 LGC M D'OR 2

06 Partagas SDC 3

any Partagas SDC 2

any VR Unicos

[Mr.T]

1. 05 SLR DC

2. 98' ERDM Tainos

3. 03' Bolivar Corona Gigantes

4. 05 Trini Fundadores

5. 07 Upmann Monarchs (tubo)

[Cambridge1]

In no order:

03 & 08 H. Upmann Sir Winston

07 Monte Especial

08 Partagas Lusitania

08 H. Upmann Mag 46

08 Partagas Serie Conn No2

[BENN]

04 Cohiba Sublimes Edicion Limitada

03 Cohiba Seleccion Reserva Robusto

03 Cohiba Seleccion Reserva Esplendidos

05 Montecristo D Edicion Limitada

04 Partagas Serie D No 1 Edicion Limitada

[Habanakane21]

Ramon Allones SS

Partagas SD4

Bolivar RC

H Upmann Magnum 50 LE2005

Bolivar Belicosos

[LeafLover]

04 Cohiba Sublimes Edicion Limitada

03 Cohiba Seleccion Reserva Robusto

03 Cohiba Seleccion Reserva Esplendidos

05 Montecristo D Edicion Limitada

04 Partagas Serie D No 1 Edicion Limitada

That's like an All-Star team!

[Laxman]

In no order,

Cohiba Grand Reserva

Sir Winstons

Partagas Lusitananas

Partagas Series D

Either the Cohiba Robusto's or Esplendedos

[mbranidis]

07 - Monte # 2's.

08 - Cohiba Siglo VI

08 - Cohiba Maduro Genios

09 - R & J LE 2009

08 - Partagas Series D # 4.

[JasonInChiTown]

No particular order

Partagas Lusitananas

Partagas SP2

Cohiba Secretos

H. Upmann Mag 48

Punch RS11

[strayvector]

For me:

Trini Fundy

Cohiba Lancero

PSD4

HU Mag 50

HU SW

[cigcars]

Stellar lists, all! My top 5:

1. COHIBA BEHIKE #56

2. BOLIVAR CENTENARY ANNIVERSARY SELECCION PYRAMIDE

3. COHIBA SIGLO IV

4. PUNCH PUNCH TUBOS

5. QUAI D'ORSAY GRAN CORONA

And Ramon Allones Gigante, Padron Family 45th Anniversaria, Monte Cristo No. 2, & Vegas Robaina Unicos for honorable mention.