Most enjoyable and disappointing cigar of the last month

[El Presidente]

Most Enjoyable: Bolivar Corona Gigante Cab 2003

Most Disappointing: HDM Petite Robusto 2004.

[Ken Gargett]

best - the HM LE 03 pyramide/cohiba siglo vi. too close to call.

worst - probably that dodgy lump of compost you fobbed off on us as first mystery cigar, though it only gets the nomination because i have stayed away from those appalling cuaba salomones you were flogging.

[El Presidente]

..that would be the Vegas Robaina Famoso which averaged a 90 rating by the 9 reviewers?

What we have here ladies and gentlemen is an LE and Cohiba snob.

.....walk away...nothing to see here :-D

[Ken Gargett]

i am what you made me.

[Cartman]

Most Enjoyed -- H. Upmann No. 2 (2001)

Most Disappointed -- El Rey Del Mundo Tainos (2000)

[SMOKOZUNA]

Most enjoyable- Partagas Series P No.2

Most Disappointing- Partagas Series D4 Reserva

[Well Armed]

I was most impressed with every one I smoked last month, and most dissapointed in those I did not.

Best: Esplendido/Unico tie

Worst: Quai d'Orsay Corona

[dragon]

Best: Trinidad Fundadore from '98

Worst: ERDM Gran Corona from '01

[shrink]

» Most Enjoyable: Partagas Lonsdale 2001»

» Most Disappointing: HDM Petite Robusto 2004.

[shrink]

ken gargett wrote:

"i am what you made me."

-reminiscent of the scene from "Blade Runner" in which the replicant Roy (Rutger Hauer) confronted his creator, Eldon Tyrell - just before he killed him.

[ironman]

Most Enjoyable: H. Upmann Super Corona from 2001, and the 04 Monte 5's

Most Disappointing:Cohiba Double Corona El...Just didn't do it for me

Ironman

[habanablue]

Most Enjoyable: RASS whilst palying golf with my old man for his 50th...9 Holes, great game, great conversation. fantastic draw and def. fresh cigar.

Least Enjoyable: RASS whilst playing golf with my old man for his 50th...trying to bloody well putt and tee off with a stogie is damn near impossible! Will have to get a cigar holder for the buggy next time!

(will have to learn a few tricks of the trade form the smoking and fishing at the same time thread!)

[Ken Gargett]

-reminiscent of the scene from "Blade Runner" in which the replicant Roy

» (Rutger Hauer) confronted his creator, Eldon Tyrell - just before he

» killed him.

no wonder you go by the handle 'shrink'.

[shrink]

Ken wrote:

» no wonder you go by the handle 'shrink'.

[josie67]

Best: RyJ Churchill

Most dissapointing: MC Edmundo

[dragon]

» Most Enjoyable: Bolivar Corona Gigante Cab 2003

»

» Most Disappointing: HDM Petite Robusto 2004.

So El Presidente....does this mean a big sale on the HDM Petite Robustos??

[Freefallguy]

Most Enjoyable: Cohiba Robusto

Most Disappointing: Cohiba Sig III

Go fig.

[Ken Gargett]

» So El Presidente....does this mean a big sale on the HDM Petite Robustos??

no big sale but a fair chance they'll go out as next month's mystery cigar.

[hawkan2580]

Most enjoyable Dunhill cabinetta -84 .. most disapointing.. must agree with el presidente here.. HDM Petite Robusto... if not taking into account a cigar box that were totally magnled in the post system.. that was disapointing too.. :-D

[rumrogue]

Me new here & soused most of the time but

Best: RyJ Hermosa No.2 LE

Worst: Ramon Allones Specially Selected from a 1998 Cabinet. Yuk! :crying:

[Freefallguy]

Rum...

For the cost of a hamburger on Tuesday, would you mind shipping those sticks my way!