What was your Best cigar of March 2012?

[El Presidente]

What was your Best cigar of March 2012?

For me it was that cracker R&J Short Churchill reviewd on the deck a few weeks ago. There is something about the Morello Cherry flavour that "Wows" me eveytime. If I close my eyes I can still taste it

[CaptainQuintero]

After watching that RYJ review I dug one out that I was gifted at Christmas, hesitated as the wrapper wasn't overtly red, infact not at all, but it delivered in spades, easy 94 cigar

Had an Upmann Grand Corona from 2001 which also got an honest 94 for me so I guess it was a draw!

Looser of the month was a Cohiba Corona Especial, everything which can be bad about a cigar was in that stick. 40/100 and that's being generous.

[brazoseagle]

Cohiba 1966 2011 EL, but a close runner up in second was 2010 Monte Grand Edmundo El !!! Both were fantastic.

[DougB]

I would have to say that it is a toss up between an 06 Mag 46 and a Ramon Allones Extra. I have smoked a ton of Extras so far and this one that I had truly floored me. Gobs of sticky figs cooked in port and lip-smacking dried apricots and marinated cherries. Verdict in- the RA Extra.

[CaptainQuintero]

I would have to say that it is a toss up between an 06 Mag 46 and a Ramon Allones Extra. I have smoked a ton of Extras so far and this one that I had truly floored me. Gobs of sticky figs cooked in port and lip-smacking dried apricots and marinated cherries. Verdict in- the RA Extra.

Dammit Doug, why the hell have all the ones I have tried tasted of dirt?!!

[danclough]

SLR Pacificos RE 2009 with Punch Sabrosos a close runner-up.

[Scdalak]

What was your Best cigar of March 2012?

For me it was that cracker R&J Short Churchill reviewd on the deck a few weeks ago. There is something about the Morello Cherry flavour that "Wows" me eveytime. If I close my eyes I can still taste it

2009 RJ Duke, Talk about Cherry!!!!

[Wil]

Gobs of sticky figs cooked in port and lip-smacking dried apricots and marinated cherries.

That is quite a description! Will have to give my single a try.

[NMJoe]

2010 Mag 46 for me on St. Paddy's Day.

[mbrody]

08 HuP Connie 1. Leather, nuts cream...spectacular.

[bacalao]

RA Superiores. All that good RA flavor but a quick burn.

[partifan]

2001 SLR DC

[Dbone]

Mights as well be named best cigar of the year, for myself. Simply outstanding rum raisin dream. These are SO good I end up chewing on the end instinctively LOL. Excellent pick Rob, dreaming of the PSP in my locker. This is an HQ box.

And to make it even BETTER, or as I call it... a little icing on the cake. This box has the best cancer sticker LOL

[CaptainQuintero]

08 HuP Connie 1. Leather, nuts cream...spectacular.

I think an extra comma is needed there!

[mbrody]

I think an extra comma is needed there!

[vanbellc]

I'm going to have to go with a HdM Epi #2

[joshb]

PSD4 I had last night!

[CanuckSARTech]

Definitely wasn't the petit corona from the blind tasting competition....

Maybe the LGC MdO No. 2 that I had a few days back....didn't have too much this past month actually. Maybe only a handful of sticks.

Bring on the spring-time weather!!!

[Lotusguy]

2001 Punch Ninfas - I am still drooling (and have another box on the way he he he )

[kcheek]

RASS I had last week, very complex.

[edlye]

RG CE from ABR 2009. Smoothness all the way, delicate flavors and floral aroma.

[vivalanation734]

2010 BRC - gave it 94 points.

[IcedCanuck]

BHK 52, not as good as the BHK 54 I had a couple months ago but still an amazing smoke!

[NMJoe]

I'm going to have to go with a HdM Epi #2

What's your box code and date? I just ordered another box and hope they live up to being the best smoke one month.

[MoneyPit]

I had two 2008 Cohiba Lanceros from an HQ box that were spectacular. They started to come around late last summer but are now really turning into something special.