Rank Your Pirimides in order of :

[El Presidente]

Rank the habanos Pirimides in order of both current preference and then again in terms of strength. It will be interesting to see the results ;-)

Diplomatico No 2

Partagas P2

Montecristo No 2

H. Upmann No 2

Romeo y Julieta Pirimide

Vegas Robaina Unicos

[gehrig24]

My #1 right now is the La Punta (I know it is not a true pirimide vitola and is a campana but to me not much difference), I consider it a medium body smoke but I have two boxes of 03 that I got from Rob that are just unreal. I am ranking medium on top to the full spectrum on bottom

Diplomatico #2

H. Upmann 2

VR Unicos

Monte #2

Partagas P2

I have not smoked enough RyJ to rank them.

[ehdg]

VR Unico

Partagas P2

Dip #2

H. Upmann #2

Monti #2

[Tampa1257]

» Rank the habanos Pirimides in order of both current preference and then

» again in terms of strength. It will be interesting to see the results ;-)

Current Production

Vegas Robaina Unicos

Partagas P2

Diplomatico No 2

Montecristo No 2

H. Upmann No 2

Romeo y Julieta Pirimide

Strength

Partagas P2

Vegas Robaina Unicos

Montecristo No 2

Diplomatico No 2

H. Upmann No 2

Romeo y Julieta Pirimide

[El Presidente]

I should post mine :-)

Current Production

Montecristo No 2

H. Upmann No 2

Vegas Robaina Unicos

Partagas P2

Diplomatico No 2

Romeo y Julieta Pirimide

Strength

Partagas P2

Vegas Robaina Unicos

Romeo y Julieta Pirimide

Montecristo No 2

H. Upmann No 2

Diplomatico No 2

[greenpimp]

Current Production:

H. Upmann No 2

Partagas P2

Montecristo No 2

Diplomatico No 2

Vegas Robaina Unicos

Romeo y Julieta

Strength:

Partagas P2

H. Upmann No 2

Vegas Robaina Unicos

Montecristo No 2

Diplomatico No 2

Romeo y Julieta

[shrink]

Edit: There are many reviewers here whose experience and judgement I respect highly. I have read no other thread that so clearly illustrates how subjective cigar preferences can be. :-|

»

» Current Production

» Partagas P2

» H. Upmann No 2

» Montecristo No 2

» Vegas Robaina Unicos

» Diplomatico No 2

» Romeo y Julieta Pirimide

»

» Strength

» H. Upmann No 2 (my ENE03's are mind-bending)

» Partagas P2

» Montecristo No 2

» Vegas Robaina Unicos

» Romeo y Julieta Pirimide

» Diplomatico No 2

[n2advnture]

Fresh:

Partagas P2

Montecristo No 2

Vegas Robaina Unicos

H. Upmann No 2

Diplomatico No 2

Romeo y Julieta Pirimide

Aged:

Montecristo No 2

Diplomatico No 2

Vegas Robaina Unicos

H. Upmann No 2

Romeo y Julieta Pirimide

* Partagas P2 - Nobody knows....

[Belicoso_Fino]

This is an easy one:

Diplomatico No 2 00's and 01's ewspecially

Vegas Robaina Unicos 99's are rockin...even recent production are very good

Partagas P2

H. Upmann No 2 - pretty good but not my favorite

Montecristo No 2

[stogies&hoagies]

» Rank the habanos Pirimides

Preference:

Party P2

VRU

Monte 2

R&J (I like R&J and it may have ranked higher if the only box I've ever bought of these were not so damn tightly rolled)

Diplo & Upmann tied

Strength: mildest to strongest:

R&J

Upman

Diplo

Monte 2

VR

Partagas

[Colt45]

I've only smoke three on the list.

Preference:

Montecristo No.2

VR Unicos

PSP2

Strength - strongest to weakest:

VR Unicos

Montecristo No.2

PSP2

[cigardawg]

I've not smoked the R&J, but here are my thoughts on the others:

Current Production:

Partagas SP#2

Vegas Robaina Unicos

Montecristo No. 2

H Upmann No. 2

Diplomatico No. 2

Strongest to Mildest:

Vegas Robainas Unicos

Partagas SP#2

Montecristo No. 2

H Upmann No. 2

Diplomaticos No. 2

[olotti]

I've also never smoked the RyJ so I'll leave that out for now.

Current Production:

VR Unicos

Partagas P2

H. Upmann no.2

Montecristo no.2

Diplo no.2

Strength

Partagas P2

Unicos

Montecristo no.2

Upmann no.2

Diplo no.2

[Ken Gargett]

had a VR unico after the mystery cigar and was reminded just how good these are. really impressed.