Recommended Posts

Posted

My apologies for the delay in posting this :lookaround:

225 respondents.

Best Biggie Cohiba Esplendido Runner up Ramon Allones Gigantes

Best Double Corona Saint Luis Rey Double Corona Runner Up Ramon allones Gigantes

Best Forum Friends of Habanos (albeit one halfwit posted Cigar Aficionado :surprised: )

Best Limited Edition Partagas Serie D No 3 Runner Up Montecristo Robusto

Best Mid-sized Cigar Cohiba Robusto Runner Up Ramon Allones Specially Selected

Best Overall Producer Partagas Runner Up Tie between Vegas Robaina and Ramon Allones

Best Piramide Tie between Partagas Serie P No 2 and the Montecristo No 2 Next Vegas Robaina Unicos

Best Small Cigar Bolivar Petit Corona Runner Up Cohiba Siglo II

Best Special Release Cohiba Seleccion Reserva Runner Up Won by a Landslide.

Cigar of the Year Tie between Partagas Serie P No 2 and Cohiba Siglo VI

Most Disappointing LE Montecristo C Runner Up Cohiba Pirimides

Most Disappointing/Worst Cigar Hoyo De Monterrey Petit Robusto Runner Up HDM PR won by a landslide

Most Inconsistent Cigar Montecristo No 2 Runner Up Partagas Short

Most Overrated Cigar Trinidad Robusto Extra Runner Up Cuaba Salomones

Most Overrated Producer Montecristo Runner Up Romeo y julieta

Most Reliable Cigar Ramon Allones Specially Selected Runner Up Cohiba Robusto

Most shameless FOH Member El Presidente in a landslide :surprised:

Most Underrated Cigar Montecristo No 4 Runner up Vegas Robaina Unicos

Most Underrated Producer Juan Lopez Runner Up Vegas Robaina

Most valuable FOH Member Ken Gargett!!!!!...you have to be kidding me. Runner Up Lisa

As a rule each winner of the category had above 40% of the first pass the post count.

Posted

Maybe I should have written down what I voted for... meh that would've taken effort. I'm pretty sure I got the shameless question right though :-P

Posted

For the life of me, I totally do not understand people that said that the Partagas Short was inconsistent? Over the years of smoking them to the tune of approximately 7-8 cabs a year, they have for me been the rock solid sweet peppery Partagas earthy and spicy flavor nuggets that are just about a daily smoke for flavor and consistency for me. Sitting here scratching my head going, what do these people smoke?

Posted

Most valuable FOH Member Ken Gargett!!!!!...you have to be kidding me. Runner Up Lisa

Runner up to Ken.....................................I will find out who voted this and you will see the wrath of a woman scorned :angry:

To you who love me :love: to the others who voted for Ken :-P

TFL

Posted

» » Best Special Release Cohiba Seleccion Reserva Runner Up

» Won

» » by a Landslide.

»

» So which cigar was runner up?:confused:

No clear runner up. The Cohiba Seleccion Reserva won with almost 70% of the vote.

Posted

Tampa wrote: For the life of me, I totally do not understand people that said that the Partagas Short was inconsistent?

Yeah, I had the same reaction when I read that. It is one of the MOST consistent cigars IMO.

Otherwise, a fair poll and very interesting results. Thanks, Rob.

Posted

I just report the results ;-) . I was a tad surprised. There was a period of tight Partagas Shorts in the last quarter of 05 which may have swayed the result.

Outside of that one of the most consistent Habanos of all.

Posted

» I just report the results ;-) . I was a tad surprised. There was a period

» of tight Partagas Shorts in the last quarter of 05 which may have swayed

» the result.

»

» Outside of that one of the most consistent Habanos of all.

Now THAT's what I hate... tight shorts!!:angry:

Posted

I cant understand that the P2 are well liked.I have smoke over 30 of them and i just don't get it.To each his own.

Posted

» I cant understand that the P2 are well liked.I have smoke over 30 of them

» and i just don't get it.To each his own.

Echo over here Jimmy2. The last one I smoked was descent but not all that.

Most inconsistant, Monte 2? oh well.

I did feel most of the results were agreable to me, not that it matters much to the rest of the world.;-)

Lisa, must be alot of fags on here. That picture of Ken was just to much for you to overcome. I know I was overcome when I saw it.:-(

Posted

Just smoke about 5 Monte #2 since Super Bowl Sunday and they never ever came close to the bland flavor of the P2.

The Monte #2 were flavor bombs layer after layer it was a big differance and reminds me why these are the best Torpedos in the world.

I think the P2 is very bland and will never buy again.But Monte#2 and H.Upmann and La Punta are on my favorte list of Torpedos.

My List the most consistant made for my taste buds....

Cohiba ROBUSTOS

SIGLO Series

BOLIVAR CORONAS GIGANTES (The Best Churchill)

Monte #2

MAGNUM 46

SAN CRISTOBAL DE LA HABANA EL PRINCIPE

SAN CRISTOBAL DE LA HABANA LA PUNTA

PARTAGAS SHORTS

BOLIVAR PETIT CORONAS

H. Upmann Monarcas

Posted

» H.Upmann and La Punta are on my favorite list of Torpedos.

Jimmy2,

Just to clarify, but the San Cristobal de la Habana "La Punta" is a Campanas, not a Pirámides or Torpedo. The Campanas is about an inch shorter than the Piramides.

Posted

» I cant understand that the P2 are well liked.I have smoke over 30 of them

» and i just don't get it.To each his own.

Good lord, Jimmy. If you don't like them why in the hell would you have smoked over 30 of them at so young an age? I haven't even tried one yet because I think it's way too soon.

Posted

» Interesting results. Always good to see the different strokes of different

» folks.

Exactly. Tastes will vary. For example I was impressed with the Trinadad extra i had.

Posted

» Most valuable FOH Member Ken Gargett!!!!!...you have to be

» kidding me. Runner Up Lisa

»

»

»

» Runner up to Ken.....................................I will find out who

» voted this and you will see the wrath of a woman scorned :angry:

»

» To you who love me :love: to the others who voted for Ken :-P

»

» TFL

I voted for you Lisa. Only a psychotic person would have voted for Ken :-P

Posted

»

» I voted for you Lisa. Only a psychotic person would have voted for Ken

how do you thing rob runs a business. no one sane is climbing on board.

may i say how delighted, after a way-too-long absence from the forum, and indeed humbled i was to come back to this. i'll need to update the cv for the moderator posting now. always great to see justice done.

and sorry about the 'cigar aficiando' vote, rob.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

Community Software by Invision Power Services, Inc.