Starting from scratch - 10 unique boxes

[Thig]

I do not think the majority of the people responding have put their 10 into any particular order or place.

Never thought of that, OK if you give each cigar just 1 point then which 10 would have the most points.

[Gamehawker]

9 minutes ago, Thig said:

32 minutes ago, Gamehawker said:

I do not think the majority of the people responding have put their 10 into any particular order or place.

Never thought of that, OK if you give each cigar just 1 point then which 10 would have the most points.

The one that has been mentioned the most of people who responded with their top 10, i,e., if H.Upmann Connie As have been on people's top 10, 30 times it would get 30 points.  

[Thig]

The one that has been mentioned the most of people who responded with their top 10, i,e., if H.Upmann Connie As have been on people's top 10, 30 times it would get 30 points.  

Right, I just need to take a minute and do the math.

[Gamehawker]

8 minutes ago, Thig said:

10 minutes ago, Gamehawker said:

The one that has been mentioned the most of people who responded with their top 10, i,e., if H.Upmann Connie As have been on people's top 10, 30 times it would get 30 points.  

Right, I just need to take a minute and do the math.

I would be a running total as more people would be posting their top 10.

[Akela3rd]

Fonseca No1

Partagas Shorts

Monte 2

Monte 5

HdM Epicure Especial

HUPC

Partagas D4

RyJ Cazadores

JLS2

CORO

 

Sent from my ActionMan walkie-talkie

 

 

 

 

[El Hoze]

HUSW

Des Dieux (not sure that counts) 

CCE

Cohiba Exquisitos (need a smaller cigar) 

Siglo V 

RyJ Churchill 

Lusi 

Partagas 898 

Fundadores 

Obligatory box of Opus X to placate the Dominican better half. 

 

[Sir Sooty]

Rough tally would put these in the top 20, starting from most popular down

RASS

PLPC

RYJ Churchill

Sir Winston

Lusitanias

Connie A

Fundadores

CORO 

P.Shorts

BRC

P.898

Punch punch

JL2

PSD4

PSE2

Esplendidos

COLA

Vigia

Siglo 3

Siglo 6

 

[HDGSN]

1. PLPC

2. Partagas 898

3. RASS (50 cab)

4. Partagas Short

5. H. Upmann Connie No. 1

6. JL No. 2

7. Punch Punch

8. Monte No. 4

9. HdM Epi No. 2

10. Cohiba Siglo IV

[Bill Hayes]

Partagas E2

Partagas 898 varnished

Cohiba robusto

Cohiba esplendidos

Montecristo especial 2

SLR DC

H Upmann Connie A

Punch Punch

ERDM Choix Supreme

BBF

[LateApex]

1.  CoRo

2.  CoLa

3.  Sir Winston

4.  PLPC

5.  Punch Punch

6.  Lusitania

7.  R&J Churchill

8.  Monte #2

9.  SCDLH La Fuerza

10. HDM DC