If you had to rank these by recent production

[olotti]

How would u rank these by their recent production:

BBF, BRC, PSP2, PSD4,

and party898 or even the EPI 2,however I have no real experience with this

cigar

[perfectform]

PSD4

BBF

898V

PSP2

BRC

Only had 1 Epi 2 so I can't comment on those, though I've heard they are great. Good luck!

[Buch0]

1. PSD4

2. BBF

3. 898V

4. PSP2

5. BRC

I would have usually put the BBF ahead of the PSD4 although I have had one or two recently that have had a real tight draw, making them virtually unsmokeable by the last third which has been disappointing.

[armedak]

EPI #2

BBF

898V

PSD4

BRC

[Rogers72]

898V

BBF

EPI #2

PSD4

The last BRC's I had were excellent but were 06.

[PigFish]

'06 Boli RC and V898 are to give a ******** for.

'07 BBF is fantastic, maybe half a ********. The '07 La Punta fits in the line above even though you did not ask.

I don't smoke the others.

[El Presidente]

How would u rank these by their recent production:

BBF, BRC, PSP2, PSD4,

and party898 or even the EPI 2,however I have no real experience with this

cigar

To be honest they have all been remarkably consistent with perhaps the exception of the P2 and D4 which can vary significantly between boxes.

BBF (07) and HDM Epi 2 (08) have been excellent. The Epi 2 a real star.

yesterday I had a TEB March 08 PSP2 which is as good a pirimide as I have had in a long while.

I probably prefer as a rule the 07 898 V over the 08's but there's bugger all in it. Just get a great box or a great singles example.

BRC have been good at worst, brilliant at best (07 & 08)

[olotti]

Thanks for the info Prez

[bassman]

Outside of the 898V, I don't buy any of those mentioned. Had my first 07 898V yesterday & it was very nice.

Now here's a curve for you. DIC 08 Quay D'Orsay Imperiales are VERY impressive. These are not mild cigars.