Dmex Posted September 11, 2025 Posted September 11, 2025 On 9/10/2025 at 12:02 AM, AndrewN23 said: If you could only smoke one cigar brand for the rest of your life, which one would you choose—and why? Would it be for the flavor profile, consistency, nostalgia, or just overall variety within the brand’s lineup? I’m really curious to hear everyone’s thoughts—if you had to commit to just one, what would be your lifetime go-to? If Andrew is buying me a lifetime supply of cigars I would say Cohiba lol. If I'm footing the bill I would say Upmann. 2
PuroDiario Posted September 11, 2025 Posted September 11, 2025 Cohiba. Tight fight behind it between Partagas and Montecristo. 2 1
Popular Post Chibearsv Posted September 11, 2025 Popular Post Posted September 11, 2025 I’ve tried to come up with an answer but I enjoy the variety and differences so much that I can’t. I’ve got so many favorites, I’d hate to give any of them up. 6
ptsmith109 Posted September 11, 2025 Posted September 11, 2025 Partagas, but to be fair I haven’t had enough Cohiba variety to opine. I’ve loved the ones I have had, though.Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk 2
zacca Posted September 12, 2025 Posted September 12, 2025 On 9/11/2025 at 10:36 PM, HuffnPuffff said: Partagas. Lusis when time is no object. D4’s when it is. 898’s when you want something a little slimmer. D5 or Shorts when you’re tight for time. P2 if it’s a leap year. Then a Salomones or a Presidente when you want to be annoyingly different. Plus they had the coolest factory in the centre of town… This would get consideration from me because when they’re on, they’re so good. But I’ve found Partagas to be the least consistent. Like a 50% success rate with the other 50% tasting like a cigarette. It’s maddening. 2
Lucas Buck Posted September 13, 2025 Posted September 13, 2025 COHIBA! You get the full range of vitolas, strength and incomparable flavors and aromas. There is no substitute. Esplendidos, Robustos, Lanceros, Siglo II, V & VI, Exquisitos & Piramides Extras are the crème de la crème. Oh and Ambar, Novedosos & Secretos! 4
JoeyBones777 Posted September 13, 2025 Posted September 13, 2025 I would have to go Fab5 on this one. Price to flavor and consistency ratio outshine every brand currently. I'm sure there will be greater variety in near future flavor wise. 2
Blazer Posted September 13, 2025 Posted September 13, 2025 1 hour ago, JoeyBones777 said: I would have to go Fab5 on this one. Price to flavor and consistency ratio outshine every brand currently. I'm sure there will be greater variety in near future flavor wise. Cough, cough, suckup, cough.🤣😇 2
Redgoldband Posted September 13, 2025 Posted September 13, 2025 Partagas. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk 2
qs210 Posted September 13, 2025 Posted September 13, 2025 Cohiba, But I would be happy with Upmann as well. 4
REesq Posted September 13, 2025 Posted September 13, 2025 If I was limited to only one cigar, it would be a BBF, but for an entire marque, it would have to be Partagas, P2's for everyday, D4's when time is short and Lusis when I want to relax, plus a plethora of vitolas for when I feel like something different. Cohiba the easy second. 2
JoeyBones777 Posted September 14, 2025 Posted September 14, 2025 7 hours ago, Blazer said: Cough, cough, suckup, cough.🤣😇 Maybe, but where's the lie in my statement?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now