Your MVP award (Most Valuable Puro).....Lifetime award.

[Cigarsmoker81]

Atm it’s the HdM Rio Seco…dependable and always good imho. Honorable mention to the Partagas E2 and QdO 54.

[zeedubbya]

This is a broad stroke here but every Cab of Lusitanias I’ve had have been superb. I haven’t bought one since 2016 but I have owned maybe 8-10 over the years and they’ve all been just wonderful and memorable. Occasional construction issue and rarely a slight dud, but overall exemplary.  

***Honorable mention will go to Dip Bushidos and PL Lonsdales (Regional release—I wish I could have tried the Reg Production PL Lonsdales or the PL Mag, but I think that ship has sailed for me now).

[joeypots]

I’ll live in the present for this one. I’m about half way through a 50 of Punch Punch, SOM AGO ’16 that are outstanding.

Past? I had a cab or RASS, ’06, that was something else. 

[Sandman]

Without a doubt my Partagas Sobresaliente humidor, or all the early boxes of PL Magnificos I smoked. Both cream of the crop in their day. Tough call.