Is Mahomes already a TOP 5 Quarterback of all time?

[VeguerosMAN]

6 hours ago, Ken Gargett said:

i think we can put a very large pin in Washington in the superbowl this season. still can't work out how we stayed so close to the ravens. always felt like they were so far ahead. Daniels was fabulous again and so was mclaurin, but the defence? how can you let a QB throw 128 passes to blokes who have no one within 10 yards. honestly, you'd be embarrassed if that was training. we are not going to the draft. just going to buy bigger witches hats because that would be an improvement. 

Considering we didn't have a run game today due to Robinson not playing, we did very well.  We will win the NFC East and will go to the Superbowl. If Eli Manning and the Giants can win 2 Superbowls with all their flaws, then we have a very good shot this year imo. 

[eddcook87]

Brady, Montana, Manning, Elway, Brees, are all ahead of him imo. But he will go down as possibly second best behind Brady when all is said and done.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

[bmac]

I think he may still be in his 20’s, but for sure he’s on a path to top 5.

[Ken Gargett]

20 hours ago, VeguerosMAN said:

Considering we didn't have a run game today due to Robinson not playing, we did very well.  We will win the NFC East and will go to the Superbowl. If Eli Manning and the Giants can win 2 Superbowls with all their flaws, then we have a very good shot this year imo. 

i think we'll absolutely do a lot better than anyone really thought but still a long way to go. you highlight a real problem. injuries. hopefully robinson minor but losing allen for the year is big. defence ordinary enough. daniels goes down and we'll be lucky to finish ahead of the giants. i'd love to be proved wrong but i don't see the defence getting us far in the playoffs this year. 

[SCgarman]

3 hours ago, Ken Gargett said:

i think we'll absolutely do a lot better than anyone really thought but still a long way to go. you highlight a real problem. injuries. hopefully robinson minor but losing allen for the year is big. defence ordinary enough. daniels goes down and we'll be lucky to finish ahead of the giants. i'd love to be proved wrong but i don't see the defence getting us far in the playoffs this year. 

Did you see former Skins owner Dan Snyder moved to London, England?! Apparently he has a 60 million dollar house in Potomac, MD and a 40 million dollar house in VA, both for sale. Apparently nobody is buying! Did he get out of dodge to escape the wrath of his bad behavior? 

[JohnnyO]

Top 5 to me would be to measure their body of work and longevity. Knowing what you know about the player would you draft him top 5? Could that player be plugged into any system and have the same results? Bradshaw and Montana had loaded teams. If Belicheck wasn't cheating or was fortunate enough to have all of those Coaching dicksteps, I doubt they would have half the Lombardi trophies they do. Brady had 112 yards passing in his 1st SB. If it wasn't for Adam Vinatieri he would have looked like Vinny Testaverde.