Rank Your Churchills

[markmurase]

1.Cohiba Esplendido

2.Upmann Sir Winston (a close 2nd to the Esplendido)

3.daylight!

[Steens]

Cohiba Esplendido, Upmann Sir Winston, Bolivar Corona Gigantes, Punch Churchill, havn't tried the others

[gersonmorelli]

This is a vitola that I really feel is missing better cigars. With the exception of the Sir Winstons, all of them are terribly inconsistent. Especially the Esplendidos which are a hit or miss with more misses than hits for the past several years.

Haven't had the Tainos yet though.

[khomeinist]

Not a fan of this size... but assuming top form....

Esplendido

QD0

Upmann Sir Winston

R&J

Few notes...

Bolivar more consistent for me than R&J, Espy, or Sir Win.

I just prefer Bolivar in smaller formats.....

QDO need several years of age IMO.....

[tdlfoto]

Seems that Upmann and Bolivar are showing most consistently. Great thread, especially for those of us looking to pick up larger format cigars for the approaching summer.

[scroggers]

For me

Boli

Cohiba

RyJ

H Upmann

[cigaraholic]

If they're all great,

Esplendido

R&J

Tianos

Winnie

[maverickdrinker]

Cohiba esplendido

Upmann sir Winston

Bolivar gigantes

[partifan]

Upmann Sir Winston by a country mile

Boli

Cohiba

QDO

[bear]

Punch, Hoyo, Boli CG, Q d'O

[thechenman]

Bolivar Gigantes

Cohiba Esplendidos

H. Upmann Sir Winstons

[nikosdoc]

1.Boli CG

2.HUpmann SirWinston

3.HdM Chourchils(discontinued)

4.R&J Chourchils(with some age)

On a side note,just picked a box of BoliCG Jun07 from Havana.The first 3 are among the best cigars i have ever had!

[dB69]

RyJ / old & well aged

Bolivar

(Party CdL)

Sir Winston

(Saint Luis Rey)

RyJ / new

Haven't smoked any other. I feel churchills are usually a bit boring, so I don't smoke them very often.