P2 vs. D4

[stargazer14]

I am a fan of of the Partagas D#4 and was wondering

if those into the brand could enlighten me on the differences between the two.

Was venturing towards a box purchase of P2's but wanted to hear some

thoughts on flavor experiences first. Thanks!

no, thats not me.

[Tampa1257]

If you enjoy the SD4, then you should enjoy the P2, the core Partagas flavors such as bold sweet green peppers, rich earth and leather add a touch of sea salt are found in both vitolas. Each has their own nuances as they do not taste identical. The P2 is a larger ring gauge cigar, so it for me is a touch milder than the SD4, but a longer smoke.

[El Presidente]

If you enjoy the SD4, then you should enjoy the P2, the core Partagas flavors such as bold sweet green peppers, rich earth and leather add a touch of sea salt are found in both vitolas. Each has their own nuances as they do not taste identical. The P2 is a larger ring gauge cigar, so it for me is a touch milder than the SD4, but a longer smoke.

Chuck nailed it

[SmokinAl]

If you enjoy the SD4, then you should enjoy the P2, the core Partagas flavors such as bold sweet green peppers, rich earth and leather add a touch of sea salt are found in both vitolas. Each has their own nuances as they do not taste identical. The P2 is a larger ring gauge cigar, so it for me is a touch milder than the SD4, but a longer smoke.

Well said Tampa. The p2 is my favourite production cigar. The D4 is fantastic but its rare I smoke one, they run out too quickly

[shrink]

The D4 is fantastic but its rare I smoke one, they run out too quickly

Al, you're right. I've often felt that way.

Rob, H.S.A. should be receptive to a Partagas Double Robusto. The Upmann Mag 50 has been an enormous hit, and a Party version should do well, too.