Corona Gorda which is the best

[Jimmy2]

The best present regular production and most consistent Corona Gorda today.

[Don Candido]

» The best present regular production and most consistent Corona Gorda today.

I have always been a fan of Siglo IV.

[smokum]

I just stocked up on this size. I am really liking Punch Royal !!.

[ccsmoker]

» » The best present regular production and most consistent Corona Gorda

» today.

»

» I have always been a fan of Siglo IV.

X 2

[El Presidente]

» The best present regular production and most consistent Corona Gorda today.

Young

Punch Royal Seleccion No 11

Bolivar Corona Extra

Cohiba Siglo IV

SLR Serie A (I am coming around to 06 stock of these)

Juan Lopez Seleccion No 1

R&J Exhibicion No 3

HDM Epicure No 1

3-5 years

Cohiba Siglo IV

Punch Royal Seleccion No 11

Bolivar Corona Exta *** can't split it with the Punch RS 11

SLR Serie A ***06's could end up with the PRS 11 but time will tell. I have a good feeling on these.

Juan Lopez Seleccion No 1

R&J Exhibicion No 3

HDM Epicure No 1

[Loki]

PRS 11 would be my choice.

[sluggo819]

Mag 46. Hands down.

[Colt45]

» Mag 46. Hands down.

I really like a good magnum 46. Unfortunately, I find them to be less than consistent.

[shrink]

You nailed it, Rob. I can't improve on this list, except maybe to tweak the order a bit:

» Young

»

» Bolivar Corona Extra

» Punch Royal Seleccion No 11

» Cohiba Siglo IV

» SLR Serie A

» Juan Lopez Seleccion No 1

» HDM Epicure No 1

» R&J Exhibicion No 3

»

» 3-5 years

»

» Cohiba Siglo IV

» Bolivar Corona Exta

» Punch Royal Seleccion No 11

» R&J Exhibicion No 3

» SLR Serie A

» Juan Lopez Seleccion No 1

» HDM Epicure No 1

[COJ]

Punch Super Selection #2

Punch Punch

Rafael Gonzales Corona Extra

H.Upmann Magnum 46

Cohiba Siglo IV

In no particlar order.

[El Presidente]

» » Mag 46. Hands down.

»

» I really like a good magnum 46. Unfortunately, I find them to be less than

» consistent.

I still haven't seenany 07 Mag 46 so I was loathe to put them in. I only had a few mid to late 06 which were very very good but I had nothing in 04/05 to rave about. In the end if the late 06 improvement continues into 07 they would be in the top half of the list.

I haven't had two consecutive great boxes of Rafael Gonzalez Corona Extra since the 2002 year. I keep looking as they are a remarkable cigar at their best. In 1998 I would have placed them in my top 3.

[tigger]

Siglo IV and HU Mag 46 for me.

[bassman]

SLR Serie A

Bolivar Coronas Extra

RyJ EX#3 (surprising as I don't like most RyJ)

and a shout to the discontinued

Punch Black Prince

ERDM Gran Corona

[Zaphod42]

» SLR Serie A

» Bolivar Coronas Extra

» RyJ EX#3 (surprising as I don't like most RyJ)

»

» and a shout to the discontinued

» Punch Black Prince

» ERDM Gran Corona

Amen, I miss the Black Prince. My favorite punch besides the SS#1.

Bolivar Corona Extra is going at the top of my Corona Gorda list.

[Curt]

»

» Amen, I miss the Black Prince. My favorite punch besides the SS#1.

»

I am rationing my last 2 boxes. If you ever get to San Diego. I'll break them out.

[log1k]

» » The best present regular production and most consistent Corona Gorda

» today.

»

» Young

»

» Punch Royal Seleccion No 11

» Bolivar Corona Extra

» Cohiba Siglo IV

» SLR Serie A (I am coming around to 06 stock of these)

» Juan Lopez Seleccion No 1

» R&J Exhibicion No 3

» HDM Epicure No 1

»

» 3-5 years

»

» Cohiba Siglo IV

» Punch Royal Seleccion No 11

» Bolivar Corona Exta *** can't split it with the Punch RS 11

» SLR Serie A ***06's could end up with the PRS 11 but time will tell. I

» have a good feeling on these.

» Juan Lopez Seleccion No 1

» R&J Exhibicion No 3

» HDM Epicure No 1

I smoked a box and a half of these in record time. Great smoke...

[Mike33]

Recent production: JL #1/Cohiba Sig IV

EL: '06 Partagas SD#3

Discontinued: Punch SS#2

[Mr. Japan]

Mag 46

JL n.1

All at least five years old.

[the dane]

» » » Mag 46. Hands down.

» »

» » I really like a good magnum 46. Unfortunately, I find them to be less

» than

» » consistent.

»

» I still haven't seenany 07 Mag 46 so I was loathe to put them in. I only

» had a few mid to late 06 which were very very good but I had nothing in

» 04/05 to rave about. In the end if the late 06 improvement continues into

» 07 they would be in the top half of the list.

»

» I haven't had two consecutive great boxes of Rafael Gonzalez Corona Extra

» since the 2002 year. I keep looking as they are a remarkable cigar at

» their best. In 1998 I would have placed them in my top 3.

still got half a box of these and they are absolutely gorgeous:-)

[Matt3]

» The best present regular production and most consistent Corona Gorda today.

I have pretty limited experience but, I like the Bolivar corona extra and the Punch Punch.