Montycristo Edmundo

[habanohal]

Tried another one of them today I still cant taste what this cigar is about. I have had 7 of them so far and all from differant sources. None of them have been close to me calling them a good cigar. Could taste a bit of the usual Monty flavor but everything else was muted.

[Chicago]

» Tried another one of them today I still cant taste what this cigar is

» about. I have had 7 of them so far and all from differant sources. None

» of them have been close to me calling them a good cigar. Could taste a bit

» of the usual Monty flavor but everything else was muted.

Same thing here. I am hoping my few remainig will awaken someday...

On the other hand, have you tried the psd2? That's a cigar!;-)

[nbuchanan2]

» Tried another one of them today I still cant taste what this cigar is

» about. I have had 7 of them so far and all from differant sources. None

» of them have been close to me calling them a good cigar. Could taste a bit

» of the usual Monty flavor but everything else was muted.

Sorry to hear, I just ordered a few for a first try :-( I had some monte 2's that went sick on me, maybe a similar deal The P2's I've had were excellant!

[idesign]

I've had one Monte Edmundo that was gifted to me and it was excellent. Don't know the date code, but I believe it was recent production (late 04).

I almost ordered some Edmundo's today, but went with RASCC's instead. Never had them, but I'm looking forward to giving them a shot...

[Ken Gargett]

i remain a huge fan of these. they have been consistently good for me.

there are quite a lot more posts on these under 'montecristo edmundo'. perhaps rob could have this all consolidated, if he has nothing better to do (nagging me is not 'something better').

[Spud2]

Compared to how they were when they arrived, they seem to be getting better with a little time in the humi!

[cf2112]

» Compared to how they were when they arrived, they seem to be getting better

» with a little time in the humi!

I liked them fresh but they are getting better, I should have saved more but I say that alot;-)

[GoatLocker]

I only tried a 5er, but I did not care for these. Pretty plain and one dimensional. I guess I'll give them another try before I give up on them...

[dysfunctional]

»dont think much of these but the ones I have smoked were all quite young...maybe with age ???

[TR]

» i remain a huge fan (nagging me is not 'something better').

lmao

[Elric]

The few that I've had have been very disappointing.

[harwellplant]

this may be the third edmundo thread in which i have now written "i like these. they are one of my favorites of the newer releases."

[ironman]

» The few that I've had have been very disappointing.

Same here, pretty one dimensional, nice.... but I like a complex cigar...

Ironman

[strayvector]

Still can't make up mind about these. I've had two and enjoyed the flavors of both, but both had draws that was just too easy. I like the size, the burn was good, initial flavor is excellent, reminded me of a stronger JL s.2, but it just was not one of those wow experiences. Solid smoke, but nothing overwhelming that you want to tell everyone about.

[novasurf]

Spell check!!!!

If it was spelled Montycristo Edmundo on the box, it was a dog rocket.

They are fairly straight forward but the last two I've had were kind on the flat side. I have none in my humi.