Off the top of your head. Best 3/worst 3 last 30 days.

[Mel]

» #1 Most Awful and still is... Cohiba Robusto

»

» #2 a close 2nd is BBF

»

» And # 3 which should be takeing the #1 is Monty #2 ( Have had 3 out of 15

» so far that were good )

Hell mate is your tongue upsidedown? I love those cigars.

Smokum, I am deeply sorry for you because my 02 Psrty coronas are some of the best cigars I own and I've got a few.

Best

Apprx. 1980 Punch Monarca tubed

Fidel Diadema

2000 Monte Robusto mellinium jar somethingorother?

Worst

Partagas SP2

Ramon Allones Estupendo(plugged)

ERDM Grandes de Espana boring and flat.

[mmblz]

Best:

BGM

70s Party SdC#3

SCdlH Muralla

Worst:

Recently had a number of really plugged cigars. All different, and none of them were actually bad cigars in general, just the particular ones I had. Don't even remember what they were.

[jadawin]

Best

PSP2

Petite Edmundo

my first Esplendido

also have to add in for a 4th, upmann connie no.1 (01 box)

Worst:

Padilla En Cedros-i dont know why i even bothered

Thats the only cigar ive had lately that i really didnt enjoy. i try not to smoke stuff anymore that i dont think i will like!

[TimL]

Best:

Ramon Allones - Eminencia

Por Larranaga Exclusivo Alemania

06 Taboada Dom

Worst:

05 Punch RS 11

06 Bolivar Belicoso

05 Bolivar PC

All of these were too young.

[El Presidente]

» ...is there a trend here?

Al little all over the place but great to see recent Monte 02's and R&J Short Churchills in the top lists and avoiding "The worst" categories.

[Professor Twain]

Best:

Cohiba Lancero (about 98)

Ramon Allones Belicoso (05)

Bolivar Coronas Junior (06)

Worst:

H. Upmann Con #1 (04)

Monte #2 (05)

RJ Coronas Grandes (02)

[Bob Loblaw]

:-) :

06 CoRo

06 PSD4

06 RASS

:-( :

06 Punch Punch

05 Monte No. 1 (plugged)

06 San Cristobal de la Habana La Punta

[Phailure]

Top:

Boli CG

Boli PC

SCdlH El Principe

Worst:

Party short...... '06

[winelover]

» Off the top of your head. Best 3/worst 3 last 30 days.

»

» Will provide mine later today.

Best 3

Vegas Robaina Don Alejandro - June 05 (had last night)

PSD4 - Jan 06

Boli CG - 2001

Worst 3

PSP#2 - May 05 - going through a terrible sick period at the mo

RASS - MAR06 - started a sickie too

Cuaba Distinguidos - actually had this a couple of months ago but it was so bad it still plagues my mind!

[jsd]

Best: RyJ Short Churchill

Monte #2

Padron 1964 Torpedo Maduro

Only really bad one lately was an 8-5-8 Maduro. I couldnt believe it but it was just terrible.