Which Should I Try First?

[cbenham73]

I have 1 box of Trinidad Reyes with a May 18 box code and 1 box of R y J Short Churchills with a code of Mar 18. Which should I continue to sit untouched? Or should allow both to continue to rest? I have had both boxes for about 8 months and never tried either cigar. 

Your advise is appreciated!

[mrmessy]

try both. take notes. check back in a requisite time frame based on your palate. life is short, smoke them.

[MigsG]

They'll both be great, try both!

[Cayman17]

I would try the Reyes and let the RyJ sit until March 2020.  

[wineguy]

1 minute ago, MigsG said:

They'll both be great, try both!

Plus one on this maybe try two

[lovethehaze]

Agreed with both comments so far. Smoke one of each and see how they are. Then wait a month and try again and so on


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[CaptainQuintero]

 Should be great to go! I'd say pick whichever you like the smell of and light up, do the other a few days later.

  It's good to make notes but at the end of the day the point is to enjoy and relax so see how the mood strikes you, there's always plenty of other cigars to do tasting notes on. 

 

[Jbhunter223]

You’ll never know if you like either if you don’t try them.  And you won’t know how they change with age if you don’t try them young.