....you have to lose one box from the humidor

[The Wise Old owl]

Punch Punch from '07. I had two boxes with different codes and both were like smoking rabbit tobbaco. I had some RASCC from '07 that were half plugged half not, the nots were OK. The suprise good cigar that, to me, is smoking best is the 2006 Partagas D3, I'm running low on them and I treasure each one now!

[Habanos2000]

I had a box of Mag 46's back in 2002 that were just bland. Had I not been so cheap and smoked them all way back, they would have been long gone.

[jwm8592]

Ahhh Professor Twain, say it ain't so. I also have a box of ABR 06 RyJ Short Churchill. well I guess if an experienced smoker like the professor is going to can that box, I would as well. Although my box is from a different factory.

[jamesward]

  beachcougar said:

Punch Double Coronas from 99. Out of almost 150 boxes it is the only box of DC's I currently own. Don't have a lot of time to smoke DC's and the weight would help as well.

Yep, that was my pick as as well. Not because I don't like double corona or have the time to smoke, more because it is just my least favorite in my locker..

[Roy R. Frush]

I'd jettison a box of "Demi Tassy". Fulfills the requirements to survive at minimal cost!