If you could trade one box from your collection today, what would it be? What would you trade it for/replace it with?

[avitus]

Ramón Allones Club Allones for any ABR 18 box of 10 (similar size or value).

[Gemini_Man]

I would swap my 2014 LGC MDO4 or PL Montecarlos for 2014 PL Picadores. 

[StoagieSnape]

PL Montecarlos for either Cohiba Exquisitos or ERDM Demi Tasse.

[BG318]

HdM Epi 2 for Sancho Panza Belicosos.

[DaBoot]

I would trade my RyJ Short Churchill. I had an amazing box back in 2017, and have been chasing that sweetness since. Haven’t found it again.

 I would trade for more HdM Petit Robustos. 

[WestCoastSmokin]

On 2/12/2026 at 11:39 AM, yuppie said:

I'd love to trade these younger boxes of Montecristo 3's and 4's for other stuff. Montecristo is super smooth, but almost boring to me. I'd rather have Sancho Panza or even RG (with serious age), SLR, Diplo or even some Upmann Regalias, Hoyo du (something thin), etc.

This is a great idea for a thread to get some trades activated in the community.

Do you want any QD50? 😂

[Mike Mecklenburg]

On 2/12/2026 at 9:50 AM, Capn_Jackson said:

A year ago, I would've said I would trade this box of Connie 2 for a box of BBF.  Then, over the course of the last year, I found myself wanting a Connie 2 at least twice a month. Now there are only one or two left, so, I guess I can't hold up my end of the trade. 😎

Those Connie 2's creep up on you