Punch Royal Coronation EML NOV 13 PQWRC

[5thStarChicago]

This gets a D- which is unfortunate as there have been since great cigars from this box.  As the pic shows, only HSA can manage to have a completely warped cigar in a straight cedar lined tubo. Even with a Perfec Draw this thing would barely draw. The headache caused by trying to pull smoke from this arc, combined with driving in downtown Chicago traffic on a rainy afternoon, makes this as almost a complete fail.  The fact that the little flavor I managed to get was decent kept it from being a solid F. 

Too bad this review didn't coincide with the "packaging fail" contest last week or I could have submitted this on two separate posts. 

Cheers! 

[FatPete]

What bad luck ! It would have been nice to read a review on this cigar, never had one, to compare it with the Punch Coronations