Picking the first cigar from the box

[Van55]

Honestly, who even thinks about crap like this? No offense intended. Just puzzled.

[maverickdrinker]

Always the one in the middle. Easiest stick to get out of the box.

[CohibaBehike]

For some reason I usually go for the ugliest one in the top row.

Me too, I always smoke through the worst looking sticks in the box first! If there are no ugly ones or messed up wrappers I don't care or have a method, I just grab a stick that I can get to easiest and smoke.

[dicko]

X2

x 3, whichever rolls out the easiest

[investandprosper]

I always take the ugliest bish of the box No matter how bad, or how good, it turns out to be, it can only go up from there!

[jimjim]

I usually pick a nice well packed one or two and place it in my desktop humidor.

[Fuzz AI]

I pick up the box, raise it to my ear and listen for the one that cries out, "Smoke me... smoke meee!!"