mk05, on 06 February 2012 - 04:18 AM, said:
"Say someone is 5'5" and 250lbs (and not a musclehead), whereas another is 6'5" and 250lbs. I would have to assume it would be much easier for the former to shed the large fat deposits and bmi relatively to the latter.
http://www.scientifi...tness/diet.html
This would at least allow for standardization of the contestants based on weight, height, and other measurements."
Unfortunately, no formula will appear fair to all types of body habitus. A weight-loss competition to win a box of cigars is not "fair" (nor healthy) for someone who is already underweight. In creating this competition, Rob had to decide what activity he wanted to encourage, and he chose weight loss. This activity is not suited for everyone. But, it is great motivation for us fatties to pursue more healthy lifestyles. Just a reading of the posts in this topic have shown me Rob has already been effective.
Rob, I applaud you for your care and concern of your clientele.
Thank you.
Bob