If it were me, I'd smoke the one on the left, assuming it even draws, to see if it tastes any good. It it's terrible, then I would dissect it. I've seen many dissected fakes and they don't do it for me.
I suffer from a rare condition known as "compulsion cigaric", caused by a chemical alteration in the brain region of the cortex, which leads to smoking cigars several times a day to relieve the deep anguish that it causes.
I assume you haven't tried many Cubans. The robusto sampler is $157 US.
Not a bad cigar in the bunch. Take notes on each and determine what flavor profile you like. Then you MAY want to buy a box or two. Splitting a box with a friend is a good beginning strategy, too.