This is me. Based on the options listed, many people must be missing the plot but to each his own. For me, I’m searching for the feelings of satisfaction vs checking a list of notes.
I mentally keep my cigars in 4 categories. Nicotine fixes (Party Short, M4, BPC), Daily Smokers, Big Smokes and Treats. Sometimes I feel like a treat, but my daily smokers (Monte 2, P2, Mag 46, BBF, Mag 50, D4, RASS, Coloniales) to me are just as enjoyable as most of my treat sticks (Trinidad Esmeralda/Topes, Cohiba Sig 3/4 and Robusto). My Nicotine Fixes are those 30 min pairing with an afternoon coffee, but my favorite cigar experiences are usually my Big Smokes paired with an activity, golfing, fishing, watching a major championship, and that’s when I smoke my Lusis, RAGs, Sir Winnies, HDM DC, RJC.